Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Access granted  Restricted Access Subscription Access

Vol 66, No 5 (2019)

Nuclear Power Plants

The EUCLID/V2 Code Physical Models for Calculating Fuel Rod and Core Failures in a Liquid Metal Cooled Reactor

Butov A.A., Zhdanov V.S., Klimonov I.A., Kudashov I.G., Kutlimetov A.E., Mosunova N.A., Strizhov V.F., Sorokin A.A., Frolov S.A., Usov E.V., Chukhno V.I.

Abstract

The article describes the basic models laid down in the second version of the EUCLID/V2 integrated code developed for carrying out end-to-end analysis of severe accidents in liquid metal cooled reactors. Brief information about the basic analogs of the code is given. Unlike the first version of the code, its second version includes additional tools for analyzing design-basis and beyond-design-basis accidents involving fuel pin, fuel assembly, and reactor core failures. To this end, the code is supplemented with additional modules using which it is possible to calculate fuel rod tightness failure as a consequence of its melting, escape of fission products into the coolant, their transport over the circuit, and release into the nuclear power plant rooms. The code also incorporates modules for calculating the core failure processes. Special attention is paid to the physical models for calculating the core materials' melting processes, motion of the produced melt, its interaction with the coolant and with other materials, and propagation of fission materials. For calculating the core failure processes, a multicomponent 3D model has been implemented. The methods used for calculating heat transfer and friction between the components are based on well-proven analytical and empirical relations for determining the heat transfer and friction coefficients. The coefficients presented in the article also depend on the obtained multicomponent flow motion regime and the type of components (metal and ceramics). The algorithms governing joint operation of the thermomechanical, thermal-hydraulic, neutronics, and the fuel rod thermal failure module are described. Emphasis is placed on data exchange methods in the course of an accident in the reactor. The approaches used for calculating the transport of fission products in the coolant and in the NPP rooms are presented.

Thermal Engineering. 2019;66(5):293-301
pages 293-301 views

Verification of the EUCLID/V2 Code Based on Experiments Involving Destruction of a Liquid Metal Cooled Reactor’s Core Components

Butov A.A., Zhdanov V.S., Klimonov I.A., Kudashov I.G., Kutlimetov A.E., Lobanov P.D., Mosunova N.A., Sorokin A.A., Strizhov V.F., Usov E.V., Chukhno V.I.

Abstract

The article presents the results obtained from verification of the EUCLID/V2 coupled code developed at the Nuclear Safety Institute of the Russian Academy of Sciences, which is intended for analysis of accident conditions in liquid metal cooled fast reactors. The additional capabilities available in the code in comparison with its first version include, in particular, analysis of individual equipment components in the 3D approximation, consideration of the transport of fission products and corrosion products in the coolant and in the nuclear power plant buildings, and also analysis of severe accidents in a fast reactor. The article presents the code verification results and assessment of its applicability for analysis of accidents involving destruction of fuel pins and the reactor core. The verification was carried out against the data obtained at experimental facilities and from analytic tests. Information about the key experiments used to validate the code is briefly outlined. In particular, data of experiments carried at the Oak Ridge, Argonne, and Sandia National Laboratory, the United States; at the National Nuclear Center of the Kazakhstan Republic; and on the test bench at the Nizhny Novgorod State Technical University (NSTU) in Russia are used. Modules of the coupled code EUCLID/V2 integrated code verification matrix are given. The errors of calculating the parameters most important for analysis of an accident’s consequences evaluated using the EUCLID/V2 code are proven with due regard to the computation and experimental results. The ranges of parameters within which the code has been verified are determined. The uncertainty and sensitivity of computation results are also analyzed based on the results from simulating certain experiments. Factors having the main influence on the computation results are determined. It is shown that the computation results are consistent with the experimental results subject to the input data uncertainty.

Thermal Engineering. 2019;66(5):302-309
pages 302-309 views

The Development of a Method for Validation of the Uncertainties of the Models Used in Thermal-Hydraulic Codes

Gritsai A.S., Migrov Y.A.

Abstract

The article deals with one of the most crucial and, at the same time, problematic stages of implementing the uncertainty analysis of thermal-hydraulic calculations by the GRS method—the validation of the statistical characteristics of model uncertainties—namely, of the circuit thermal-hydraulic block’s closing relations. The above relations developed, as a rule, on the semiempirical approach, are one of the main sources of uncertainty of the results calculated by the code. A task of developing the method proposed by the authors earlier that allows performing the validation procedure using verification technology and objective statistical criteria was set. The method in question allows going from an expert evaluation to the objective assessment of the model parameter uncertainties, thus enhancing the objectivity of the calculated results obtained within the framework of the GRS method. Particular problems are formulated the solution of which expands the capabilities of the method to use experimental information and to assess the uncertainties of the model parameters that cannot be directly measured experimentally. This, in turn, allows using the method for validation of the uncertainty of all most-critical model parameters of the design code. The stages of the proposed method are set forth sequentially followed by discussion of the topical problems that arise at every stage. Using practical examples, the ways of solving the formulated problems are demonstrated. The results obtained using the method for evaluation of uncertainties of a series of model parameters (closing relations) of the KORSAR thermal-hydraulic design code are provided. The results are recommended for use when analyzing uncertainties within the framework of the KORSAR code by the GRS method. Moreover, the proposed method can also be applied to other design codes.

Thermal Engineering. 2019;66(5):310-315
pages 310-315 views

Steam Turbine, Gas Turbine, and Combined-Cycle Power Plants and Their Auxiliary Equipment

Fuel Utilization Monitoring Techniques for Large-Capacity Combined-Cycle Power Plants

Ol’khovskii G.G., Trushechkin V.P., Ageev A.V., Tuz N.E., Teplov B.D., Rozhkov A.D.

Abstract

A technique for calculating the standardized indicators characterizing the thermal efficiency of combined-cycle power plants (CCPPs) using correlation equations linking the values of these indicators with different external conditions is proposed. The correlation equations were written using the results from measuring the outdoor air and cooling water temperatures; air barometric pressure and humidity; fuel (natural gas) flowrate, heating value, and density and load in steady-state operation modes of the CCPPs and their equipment. It is usually sufficient to have a sample with three groups each representing 15–20 operating modes: under winter conditions at an outdoor air temperature of –20 to –30°С, under summer conditions at an outdoor air temperature of above 20 to 30°С, and at an intermediate temperature of ±5 to ±7°С. In each group, it is sufficient to have two operating modes each with loads close to 0.5, 0.6, 0.7, 0.8, and 0.9 of the maximal value, and 5–10 operating modes with a close-to-nominal load. It is shown, taking a single-shaft 400 MW CCPP as an example, that the correlation equations adequately (with errors equal to approximately 1%) describe the results obtained experimentally in the normal operation modes. The developed technique opens the possibility to determine, in a more accurate and simple manner, the standardized heat rates and other technical-economic indicators of fuel utilization without using an excessive number of corrections able to distort the result. The technique can also be used for estimating the changes of CCPP indicators as a result of taking some or other measures in them.

Thermal Engineering. 2019;66(5):316-322
pages 316-322 views

Improving Flexibility and Economic Efficiency of CCGT Units’ Operation in the Conditions of the Wholesale Electricity Market

Teplov B.D., Radin Y.A.

Abstract

The issues of improving flexibility and operation modes of combined-cycle plants with three-pressure heat-recovery steam generators (CCGT with HRSG) are considered in the conditions of the wholesale electricity market. Operation modes of high-performance CCGT units, which were designed mainly for the basic operation mode with a minimum number of starts and load variations are significantly different from it due to the lack of regulatory capacities in power systems. The increasing CCGT unit fractional load running time, emerging role of ramping to the minimal possible load, and expediency of involving the CCGT unit to adjust the frequency and power in the power system make it necessary to extend their adjustment load range limits. The article analyzes the possibilities and the need for maximum CCGT ramping during the night-time valley from a technical and economic point of view. The factors limiting the CCGT load range are obtained computationally and experimentally. The ways to reduce the technological minimum CCGT load are considered by heating the compressor inlet air, bypassing part of the compressed air to its inlet, and enhancing its flow control using inlet guide vanes (IGV) as well as combining these methods. The influence of the electricity price in the day-ahead market on the optimal generating capacity load is analyzed. The optimization of the CCGT operating modes in the conditions of the wholesale electricity market is carried out with allowance for the developed load range extension methods.

Thermal Engineering. 2019;66(5):323-330
pages 323-330 views

Steam Boilers, Power-Plant Fuels, Burner Units, and Boiler Auxiliary Equipment

Investigation Tests of the P-134 Heat-Recovery Steam Generator Used as Part of the PGU-230T Combined-Cycle Power Unit

Maidanik M.N., Tugov A.N., Mishustin N.I., Zelinskii A.E.

Abstract

Investigation tests of the P-134 heat-recovery steam generator (produced by PJSG Zio-Podolsk) used as part of the PGU-230T combined-cycle power unit at the Chelyabinsk combined heat and power plant no. 3 (CHPP-3) were carried out, as a result of which experimental data on the steam generator thermal parameters have been obtained, and adequacy of the thermal–hydraulic design analysis model developed by PJSG ZiO-Podolsk has been confirmed. A description of the heat-recovery steam generator is given along with schematic arrangements of experimental instrumentation, test conditions and techniques, and experimental data processing methods. A procedure and computer program for estimating the steam generator thermal parameters, and a procedure for reducing the test results to design conditions are elaborated. It has been determined that the total thermal power of heating surfaces in the steam–water path deviates from the steam generator total thermal power directly measured at the boundary balance sections by no more than 0.84%. The steam generator thermal power values determined with reference to the steam–water and gas paths differ from each other by no more than 1.7%. The steam generator thermal power obtained in the tests differs from its design value by no more than 2.4%, and it should be noted that its value measured in all operating modes was higher than its design value. The design thermal power values of the high-pressure loop heating surfaces reduced to the test conditions differ insignificantly (and toward increasing) from their actual values. The obtained results demonstrate that the analysis models can be used for reducing the test results to the heat-recovery steam generator operating conditions (parameters) at which the conformity of their values is established for confirmation (assessment) purposes, in particular, in carrying out warranty tests. It has been shown that the heat recovery steam generator’s thermal power reduced to the warranty conditions that was obtained in all test modes is somewhat higher than the design thermal power under the warranty conditions.

Thermal Engineering. 2019;66(5):331-339
pages 331-339 views

Configuration of Evaporators for Once-Through Heat Recovery Steam Generators of Combined-Cycle Units

Gorr D.A., Polonsky V.S., Tarasov D.A.

Abstract

Various designs are examined of evaporators for horizontal or vertical once-through heat recovery steam generators (HRSG) of combined-cycle units. Special attention is given to the Benson boilers manufactured by Siemens, which are most widely used now. Vertical HRSG with evaporators having horizontal heating surface sections are also analyzed. Their advantages and disadvantages are outlined. It is demonstrated that HRSGs with vertical heating coils provided with equalizing headers are more advantageous. The equalizing headers are connected with stubs to bottom U-bends of the coils. All heating surfaces are drained by gravity. The temperature conditions of this evaporator were investigated in a GTU load range of 25–100%. It has been found that partial load operation results in poorer heat transfer due to the boiling crisis. However, the maximum temperature jump in the post dryout region will be approximately 25–30°С, which is quite acceptable for reliable operation of low-alloy steel tubes. Assessment of the flow stability at the precrisis conditions demonstrates that the two-phase flow in the evaporator is stable over the applicable load range of HRSG. The calculations were performed for the evaporator without an orifice at the coil inlets. On the whole, the thermal-hydraulic operating conditions of these boilers are much better than those of Benson boilers. From the construction standpoint, a coil evaporator with equalizing headers is simpler and less metal intensive. A quite high liquid velocity is kept at all loads. Dynamic properties are also advantageous, since the material and the geometry of metal intensive elements of the evaporator, such as separators and water tanks, have been selected to improve performance of the overall HRSG.

Thermal Engineering. 2019;66(5):340-349
pages 340-349 views

Heat and Mass Transfer and Properties of Working Fluids and Materials

Boiling of Liquid Subcooled to Saturation Temperature in Channels as a Method for Removal of Ultimate Heat Fluxes

Vasil’ev N.V., Zeigarnik Y.A., Khodakov K.A., Maslakova I.V.

Abstract

The results of a comprehensive experimental study of the boiling of water subcooled to the saturation temperature in a channel are presented. This technology is used to remove extreme heat fluxes in modern equipment. An emphasis is placed on the study of the characteristics of vapor bubbles, their changes under the effect of various regime factors, and characteristics of the heating surface. For the realization of the goals, a high-speed video of the process was used. Experiments were carried out with distilled deaerated water at atmospheric pressure, heat flux densities of up to q = 8 MW/m2, subcooling of the liquid to the saturation temperature of Δts = 30–80°C, and the flow velocity of the liquid of up to w = 0.7 m/s. Smooth and structured surfaces with coatings, most of which were produced by microarc oxidation, were used in the experiments. Significant subcooling of the liquid to the saturation temperature is shown to cause a deep deactivation of the active nucleation cites after the collapse of the vapor bubble and spatial and temporal randomness of the distribution of the nucleation cites over the heating surface. The bubble size distribution, the density of nucleation cites that is approximately proportional to the heat flux density, the bubble lifetime, and the duration of individual stages of its life cycle are determined. A picture of the bubble collapse is clarified. The subcooling of the coolant to the saturation temperature is shown to be the strongest among the parameters that determine the boiling of the subcooled liquid. The phenomenological Snyder–Bergles model of the boiling process was established to agree best with the measurement results. Such engineering aspects of the problem as the choice of limiting design parameters of the cooling system and the use of coatings for boiling enhancement of a subcooled coolant are considered.

Thermal Engineering. 2019;66(5):350-360
pages 350-360 views

Energy Conservation, New and Renewable Energy Sources

Comprehensive Utilization of Low-Potential Geothermal Waters of Southern Russia for Heat and Water Supply and Solution of Environmental Problems

Alkhasov A.B., Alkhasova D.A.

Abstract

The current state of exploitation of low-potential thermal waters of the East Ciscaucasia Artesian Basin has been evaluated. Low-potential waters, which are the only source of water supply for a considerable number of consumers in the North Caucasus, are being exploited in an extremely inefficient way with at most 20% of the allocated resources being utilized to the fullest extent. Abusive exploitation of the wells resulted in the bogging of large areas around them, depletion of water resources, and deterioration of the latter as a consequence of backflow of low-quality water from adjacent horizons into those being exploited. The quality of the water has drastically deteriorated; in most wells, contaminants, such as arsenic and various organic compounds, have been detected in quantities that considerably exceed the maximum permissible concentrations set for potable water. These thermal waters are not being used for generation of heat and power since their temperature is too low for heat and hot-water supply purpose. However, the resources of low-potential waters are sufficient to solve the problems of heat and hot-water supply and to provide a considerable number of consumers in the region with potable and process water provided that these resources are exploited in a sensible way using new complex technologies. Complex engineering systems comprise a system of heat pump plants in which the low-potential heat of thermal waters is utilized and a chemical treatment plant in which the cooled water is purified from contaminants, thus raising its quality to the potable water standard. The designs and technological parameters of the chemical treatment plants differ depending on the composition and amount of contaminants. The complex systems allow utilization of the product of thermal artesian wells to the fullest possible extent and large-scale introduction of such systems will facilitate the solution of environmental and economic problems in the region and improve sanitary, hygienic, social, and living conditions of people.

Thermal Engineering. 2019;66(5):361-366
pages 361-366 views

Heat Supply and Heating Networks

Bellows Expansion Joints of the Main Heating Network Pipelines: Problems and Damage Prevention

Tomarov G.V., Shipkov A.A.

Abstract

The problems of bellows expansion joints conditioned by their design features and the quality of the heat carrier are considered. It is testified that typical damage of bellows expansion joints are deformations, changes in geometric characteristics, and through defects of structural elements. Prevention and timely detection of damaged bellows expansion joints is an important task of the heating system’s operation. Examples of damage to bellows expansion joint elements are presented, including those with corrosive destruction of pearlitic steel corrugated inner layers and outer high-alloyed steel corrugations. Some survey results are presented and factors are analyzed that may affect the damageability of bellows expansion joints of the main heating network pipelines at PAO MOEK1. The causes and dominant damage mechanism of bellows expansion joints, caused by the formation of crevice defect with penetration of the heat carrier into the inner space of the pearlitic steel corrugated layers, have been established. Practice has shown that most of the damage is detected in pressure testing and is associated with mechanical deformations of the bellows without depressurization and without unsealing and loss of the heat carrier. Four main corrosion and damage stages of heating system bellows expansion joints are identified. It is proposed, depending on the initial and operating conditions, to consider possible scenarios of a two-stage mechanism of destruction of bellows expansion joints, including the development of a crevice defect up to the through leakage of heat carrier into the bellows interlayer space and corrosion damage to the inner corrugated bellows surface. Recommendations to prevent damage to bellows expansion joints of heating systems are provided.

Thermal Engineering. 2019;66(5):367-371
pages 367-371 views

Water Treatment and Water Chemistry

Adsorption Treatment of Reverse-Osmosis Concentrate from Water-Treatment Units at Thermal Power Stations

Nikolaeva L.A., Minneyarova A.R.

Abstract

Make-up water is treated at thermal power stations (TPS) with high-pressure or superhigh pressure boilers using membrane processes implemented in ultrafiltration, microfiltration, or reverse-osmosis (RO) units. Among the criteria of the efficiency of reverse osmosis units is the amount of highly mineralized effluents (or concentrate). At present, the RO concentrate is disposed of at TPSs by discharging it into an industrial sewage system in accordance with the applicable standards on the salt content limit of waste water, routing it into a district heating network, or returning it into recirculation water supply systems, decreasing as far as possible the volume of the discharged concentrate which is to be reused, for example, in regeneration of Na-cation exchangers installed upstream of the reverse-osmosis unit. The adsorption process is proposed for treatment of the reverse-osmosis concentrate using sludge from the makeup water treatment. The characteristics of carbonate sludge are presented. The regularities of adsorption of sulfate- and chloride-anions from the RO concentrate by carbonate sludge are described. An adsorption isotherm was obtained. The mechanism of adsorption on a sorption material is proposed. The effect of pH on adsorption of sulfate- and chloride-ions by a sorption material was investigated. A system is proposed for the treatment of the concentrate from the RO units at the Kazan Cogeneration Power Station TETs-2 to remove sulfate- and chloride anions using a three-stage adsorption method with a counter-current injection of the sorbent, namely, the carbonate sludge. The calculated values of the consumption of the sorption material required to achieve the desired residual concentration of sulfate- and chloride-anions in the treated water are presented. The economic effectiveness from implementation at the Kazan TETs-2 of the adsorption treatment of the RO concentrate by carbonate sludge to remove sulfate- and chloride-ions is estimated.

Thermal Engineering. 2019;66(5):372-376
pages 372-376 views