Vol 16, No 4 (2022)

New Research

Influence of CEO Human Capital and Behavioral Characteristics on Economic Profit of Russian Companies

Nazarkina V., Gostkov D., Lapteva A., Kniazev V., Ivashkovskaya I.

Abstract

We investigate how different personal traits of a chief executive officer (CEO) influence value creation in one of the largest emerging capital markets in Russia. Our research model considers several components of human capital of a CEO.

Moreover, we include CEO’s behavioral biases looking at overconfidence measured by industry adjusted ratio of capital expenditures and narcissism captured by the analysis of CEO’s photos following previous academic research approaches. The CEO power is applied to understand its impact over value creation and possible mitigating effect. Our sample consists of 111 Russian publicly traded companies and 235 CEOs for 8 years (from 2013 to 2020). We apply economic profit criteria to measure corporate performance with economic value added (EVA) which captures the spread between actual return on capital derived from financial reports and overall cost of capital based on the risks of a company collected from Bloomberg .

We use first-order differences in company’s contribution to EVA after adjustments to the industry and overall market contributions to EVA for the sample. We find empirical evidence that CEO’s human capital affects value creation measured by first-order differences to industry adjusted EVA yearly. Furthermore, the CEO power has positive impact over value creation in Russian corporations while behavioral biases such as overconfidence ad narcissism do not have significant relationship with the changes in EVA.

Journal of Corporate Finance Research. 2022;16(4):6-33
pages 6-33 views

Do CEO Behavior Biases and Personal Traits Influence ESG Performance? The Evidence from Emerging Capital Market of Russia

Lazareva E.

Abstract

The impact of behavioral biases and personal traits of the CEO on corporate decisions and performance has become the important agenda for management, governance and finance research. But still the empirical evidence on the influence of behavioral biases on the implementation of sustainability principles into company’s strategies is missing not only in
emerging markets, but for developed markets as well. We aim to fulfill this gap by findings on the role of behavioral characteristics of a CEO and how they affect the effectiveness of the ESG (Environmental, Social and Corporate Governance) approach to company management in one of the largest emerging capital market of Russia. We first focus on CEO’s optimism,
narcissism, self-confidence, and the lack of confidence of the CEO and their impact over ESG performance. To identify behavioral biases, we use textual analysis and the “bag of words” method applied to the written letters to the shareholders by CEOs of Russian companies in 2017–2019 on a sample of 38 companies with official external ESG ratings.


Our results confirm a significant influence of optimism and narcissism on the effectiveness of the ESG approach, but self-confidence does not appear to be statistically significant. Moreover, our findings prove significance of some personal traits such as industry experience and technical educational background. Our findings validate and complement prior research on personal characteristics of CEOs and provide novel data on the impact on ESG in emerging capital markets.

Journal of Corporate Finance Research. 2022;16(4):72-92
pages 72-92 views

How CEO Affects ESG and the Financial Performance of Companies

Farrakhova I.

Abstract

In the past decade the society grew more interested in corporate operations concerning environmental, social, and corporate governance (ESG). This paper is dedicated to study of influence of CEO’s personal characteristics on financial performance of companies and interrelation between ESG indicators and corporate financial performance. For this purpose
we have conducted a review of scientific literature on this topic, established interrelation between financial indicators and ESG indicators, determined the main characteristics which influence corporate financial indicators. For this purpose we developed a model of CEO’s personal characteristics. The paper studied characteristics of CEOs from Russian companies, compiled a rating of CEOs taking into consideration financial and ESG indicators of companies, considered influence of the CEO’s position in this overall rating on financial
indicators of a company.


The research sample comprises 81 Russian companies of the real sector which are in the Moscow Exchange index and 123 CEOs. The time interval covered by this research is seven years since 2013 to 2019. Analysis was performed in the statistics package STATA applying panel data analysis as a method. Return on assets, return on equity and the market capitalization
indicator were used as dependent variables. We chose disclosure of ESG information by a company, CEO’s score in the overall rating and such CEO’s characteristics as age, tenure and financial education as explicative variables. Financial leverage and company size were used as control variables. We also added return on assets to some model specifications in
order to improve the model quality.

Journal of Corporate Finance Research. 2022;16(4):93-118
pages 93-118 views

Impact of CEO Overconfidence on M&A Performance in the US: A Content Analysis

Grigorieva S., Kirakosyan M.

Abstract

Despite the high activity on the market for corporate control, more than 60% of M&As are unsuccessful and contribute to damage to the value of the acquiring company. We still have little evidence on the impact of M&A deals in different countries and industries on shareholer value, as well as the factors that influence this impact. Academic researchers and practitioners continue to seek out the factors that influence M&A performance, but results are still inconclusive, indicating the need for further research into acquisition performance and factors that influence the overall success of M&A deals. This paper examines the impact of CEO overconfidence on the performance of M&A deals in the United States. In contrast to previous studies, we, first of all, use earnings call transcripts in content analysis as the base to measure CEO overconfi-dence; secondly, we apply cluster analysis to identify the factors that force CEOs to structure their speech during earnings calls in a similar manner; and, thirdly, we assess the impact of CEO overconfidence on the performance of high-tech deals. The study is based on a sample of 492 M&A transactions implemented during the post-crisis period, 2009–2019. Using the event study method to assess the performance of M&A deals and regression analysis, we prove that CEO overconfidence has a negative impact on the success of M&As. However, when considering a subsample of deals in which the target com-pany operates in a high-tech industry, we failed to identify a significant impact of overconfidence on M&A performance. As a result of cluster analysis, we identified a cluster of 165 companies with a common structure and similarity of CEO speeches, which are not explained by the companies’ affiliation with similar industries. This suggests that overconfident CEOs tend to use and structure their speeches similarly.

Journal of Corporate Finance Research. 2022;16(4):34-45
pages 34-45 views

CEO Age and Cash Holdings around the World: The Moderating Role of Legal Origin

Yeoh S., Hooy C.

Abstract

The worldwide growth in the level of corporate cash holding has prompted scholarly interest. Grounded on the precautionary motive of cash, we aim to provide a behavioural explanation to this phenomenon by exploring the relation between CEO age and corporate cash holdings. We further examine the institutional factor that may exert an influence on this relationship through a country’s legal systems, based on the notion that business corporations are part and parcel of the nexus of the institutions. Using an international sample of 24,989 firms from 90 countries, we find that CEO age is positively associated with the level of cash holdings. The positive impact is weakened when firms operate in countries with greater investor protection and better financial development. We demonstrate that older CEOs from common law, German law and post-socialist countries have a propensity to hold less cash. Additional robustness test supports our empirical findings.

Journal of Corporate Finance Research. 2022;16(4):46-60
pages 46-60 views

How Does CEO’s Human Capital Influence Innovation Strategy of Russian Banks?

Fedorova A.

Abstract

The paper evaluates influence of human capital of top management on innovation strategy on the basis of study of innovation activity of Russian commercial banks in the period of 2017–2019. We have compiled a rating of commercial banks for retail segment innovations, selected the four least innovative banks. We have studied the key indicators of human capital
of top management in eight chosen banks. The paper has revealed the interrelation between different elements of human capital of top management and innovation strategies of Russian commercial banks. We have defined personal traits which portray a manager who exerts influence on innovations in a company.

The paper is intended for investors in emerging markets which try to understand the evaluation mechanisms of impact of the financial companies’ current management on their future development path, for analysts engaged in forecasting trends related to optimization and automation in retail banking and assessment of corporate innovative capacity.

Journal of Corporate Finance Research. 2022;16(4):61-71
pages 61-71 views

Reviews

Relationship between Board Characteristics, ESG and Corporate Performance: A Systematic Review

Popov K., Makeeva E.

Abstract

In recent years researchers have been paying significant attention to Environmental, Social, Governance (ESG) principles as a crucial factor in company performance. This paper aims to summarize the trends and findings in academic literature devoted to the board of directors as a determinant of ESG performance and non-financial disclosure quality. This paper also summarizes the key findings for a board’s moderating effects on the impact of ESG on corporate financial performance. The results of qualitative analysis of more than 70 empirical papers demonstrate that board independence is the most widely considered parameter, interpreted as a positive factor for strengthening a board’s monitoring function according to agency theory. There is no consensus on board size: larger boards include directors who represent the interests of a wider range of stakeholders (stakeholder theory), however, the increase in board size leads to a complication
of decision-making and controlling processes. Researchers mostly agree that an augmentation of women’ and foreigners’ representation among directors positively affects ESG performance and disclosure quality, although the lack of critical mass may dilute this effect. As for CEO’s role in the board, while some researchers argue that CEO duality enhances agency conflict, deterring corporate transition to ESG, other authors claim that a CEO’s organizational power may enhance the ESG transition due to a faster implementation of board decisions. One of the crucial determinants for this effect is the board members’ diversified professional expertise, including specialized education and experience, for the effective monitoring of managers’ performance. Finally, there is a growing interest in the role of board sustainability committees,
which accumulate the required professional expertise for developing environmental and social strategies (resource-based theory). By examining the key board characteristics’ effect on corporate ESG performance and disclosure quality, this paper contributes to corporate governance literature, expanding the field for further research. Moreover, the paper highlights several understudied issues for further research.

Journal of Corporate Finance Research. 2022;16(4):119-134
pages 119-134 views

Why Do We Need to Examine Leadership Concepts and Styles in Finance? Literature Overview

Kurdyukov N.

Abstract

In the contemporary world, leadership concepts are associated with managerial literature. As a rule, scholars define a leader as a person with a certain set of positive characteristics that enable them to lead people and contribute to the successful development of a company. However, the concept of financial efficiency has to be factored into the effective development of a company. At the same time, personal characteristics of top managers, such as overconfidence, narcissism, excessive risk-taking, usually have a negative connotation in financial literature.

This review includes a study of the development of various leadership concepts in management-related literature. The leader’s main personal characteristics are highlighted according to the literature. It also explores the relationship between the concepts of a leader and a manager. The literature devoted to the relationship between the concept of a transformational
leader and company performance has also been studied. The key conclusion of this literature review is that certain personal characteristics of top managers can have a positive
effect on a company’s performance if they are considered from the point of view of transformational leadership. This confirms the need for a deeper study of the relationship between managers’ personal characteristics and a company’s financial efficiency, especially in the context of sustainable development and the concept of transformational leadership.

Journal of Corporate Finance Research. 2022;16(4):135-143
pages 135-143 views