Vol 17, No 2 (2023)

New Research

M&A Prediction Model-Based Investment Strategies

Fokina E., Elizariyev G.

Abstract

In this paper, we study the development of investment strategies by predicting M&A deals using a logistic model with the financial and non-financial indicators of public companies. A random sample of 1510 acquired and non-acquired companies in Germany, the United Kingdom, France, Sweden, and Russia over the period 2000-2021 was used to design an M&A logit prediction model with high predictive power. The use of interaction variables significantly improved the model’s predictive power and allowed it to obtain more than 70% of correct out-of-sample predictions. Then the model’s ability to generate abnormal returns was tested with the help of an event study using share price data over the period 2011-2021. We show that an M&A prediction model can also efficiently generate abnormal returns (up to 49% on average) for a portfolio of companies that are expected to be acquired. Moreover, we uncover evidence that reduction in false positive and negative predictions has a positive effect on abnormal returns due to the added model flexibility resulting from interaction terms. Our positive theoretical and empirical results can help both private and institutional investors to design investment strategies. In addition, there are indirect implications that support the practical importance of an efficient M&A prediction model.

Journal of Corporate Finance Research. 2023;17(2):5-26
pages 5-26 views

Evaluation of Impact of ESG Rating and Environmental Performance Factors on the Level of Credit Risk and Shareholder Expectations of Companies in Carbon-Intensive Industries from BRICS Countries

Agranat V.

Abstract

The objective of the study was to evaluate the impact of ESG ratings, environmental (E) pillar scores and environmental performance metrics of non-financial companies from BRICS countries on their credit risks (measured by credit rating) and shareholder expectations (measured by enterprise value (EV) to sales multiple). Environmental performance metrics included emission scores, water efficiency scores, environmental management team scores and the ability to cope with climate risks scores. The relevance of the study is underpinned by the limited number of research in the field for BRICS countries and contradictory conclusions in research about the strength and direction of the influence of ESG factors on the value and financial metrics of the companies. The ordered logit regression and OLS regression models were applied for credit ratings and EV/Sales multiple respectively. The sample included 206 companies from carbon-intensive industries from Brazil, China, India, South Africa and Russia for 2018-2021. Financial and ESG metrics were taken from Refinitiv while companies' credit ratings were taken from Moody’s and S&P. The results showed that the improvements in ESG and E-scores as well as environmental performance metrics hurt companies’ credit ratings. Conversely, the improvements in ESG, E-scores and environmental performance metrics had a positive impact on EV/Sales metrics. The latter confirms the TGMT (too-much-of-a-good-thing) effect of environmental performance as equity investors expect a positive effect from climate-related actions on equity performance in the long term.

Journal of Corporate Finance Research. 2023;17(2):68-84
pages 68-84 views

Dynamic Maintenance of Solvency of the Russian Insurance Companies: the Evidence from Russian Insurers

Tsvetkova L.

Abstract

The Russian economy is facing sanctions pressure, resulting in weakening business relations with foreign insurers. Medium-sized insurance companies, targeting regional economic entities, play a crucial role in the insurance market. To improve the efficiency of Russian insurance, the number of medium-sized companies operating in regional markets must increase. To regulate their capitalization, special conditions must be developed, focusing on capital adequacy requirements and financial stability parameters. While earlier research has examined what factors might impact profitability growth, the investment income factor in maintaining corporate financial stability has been underexplored. This paper aims to explore conditions for improving insurers' financial soundness through growth of a company's internal capitalization. Medium-sized insurance companies often struggle to meet regulators' minimum capital requirements (a core variable linked with companies’ capitalization) leading to potential market shrinkage. Our hypothesis is that it possible to create a financial reserve that meets the regulator’s increasing equity requirements without raising additional external investments. This study examined the factors which impacted the growth of medium-sized insurance companies operating in the emerging markets. Operating results of seven randomly selected medium-sized insurance companies in 2014–2022 were used for the analysis. The paper suggests that institutionalization of insurance companies' capitalization is crucial to minimize the risk of capital inadequacy. The study contributes to our understanding of how medium-sized insurance companies can be governed and suggests a way to increase their capitalization.

Journal of Corporate Finance Research. 2023;17(2):85-94
pages 85-94 views

Impact of Board of Directors on Funds Raising: Evidence for Green Bonds

Potapova E.

Abstract

The present paper attempts to reveal influence of characteristic features of the board of directors (BD) on fund raising using green bonds. The research involved a sample of 87 public companies which issued green bonds in 2021. We analyzed influence of such factors as the proportion of women and independent directors on the BD, CEO duality and the number of the BD members by the share of green bonds in the total debt of the company. The share of debt in the assets, the natural logarithm of total assets (company size) and return on equity (ROE) were used as control variables.

The logarithmic specification of the classical linear regression model was chosen as the optimal one. So, heteroscedasticity, autocorrelation and multicollinearity were not detected in the model with the dependent variable logarithm (the share of green bonds in the total debt). The least squares method (LSM) was applied to evaluate this model. As long as the initial sample of companies which issued green bonds in 2021 comprises both financial and non-financial companies we verified the validity of the obtained results for two types of companies. Assessment of the optimal model for two subsamples of financial and non-financial companies yielded results somewhat different from the ones obtained from analysis of the total sample. Evaluation of the regression for financial and non-financial companies showed a reduction in significance of influence exerted by women’s representation and the size of the BD. However, in case of non-financial companies the significance of such factor as presence of the sustainable development committee increases. According to the obtained results the companies with the CSR committee attract relatively larger financing using green bonds.

Journal of Corporate Finance Research. 2023;17(2):27-38
pages 27-38 views

Voluntary Delisting of Russian Companies at Different Stages of Corporate Life Cycle

Kizko I., Cherkasova V., Grigorieva S.

Abstract

Nowadays, the number of companies leaving the stock exchange is steadily increasing. Researchers and practitioners continue to actively discuss the reasons for voluntary delisting and explore the factors that influence the probability of it. However, the results of existing studies are heterogeneous and inconclusive, indicating the need for further research. This paper continues the line of research on the determinants of voluntary delisting by studying the delisting of Russian companies. Unlike previous studies, we identify and compare the factors that influence the decision to delist at different stages of the organization’s life cycle. We argue that delisting factors, although specific to each company, should remain similar for firms at the same stage of development. The company-related factors that we test include investment expenditures, profitability, stock volatility and book-to-market ratio. The study is based on a sample of 162 public Russian companies traded on the Moscow Exchange, of which 75 delisted between 2011 and 2019. The Bloomberg database was used to generate the sample of companies. Using the panel probit regression model, we found that firms with greater investment expenditures are less likely to delist at the Introduction and more likely at the Maturity and Decline stages. The results of our research also show that firm stock volatility had a positive effect on the delisting probability of Russian firms at all stages of their life cycle, except for the Introduction stage. Finally, we demonstrate that companies at the Introduction and Growth stages are more likely to leave the stock exchange if they have a greater book-to-market ratio. The results of our study can be used by financial analysts and academics to analyze the probability of delisting of public companies at different life cycle stages.

Journal of Corporate Finance Research. 2023;17(2):39-49
pages 39-49 views

The Impact of Sanctions on the Capitalization of Russian Companies: The Sectoral Aspect

Fedorova E., Nevredinov A., Chernikova L.

Abstract

The research purpose is to evaluate influence of sanctions on the Russian economy taking into consideration the sectoral aspect (oil and gas, telecommunications and consumer sector). The research methodology comprises econometric modeling (elastic net and GARCH modeling) and text analysis. In the paper we developed author’s sanction indices based on the text analysis. We used the EcSentiThemeLex dictionary to assess the news’ positivity and negativity. The empiric research base consists of news publications of the lenta.ru portal for the period from 01.01.2014 to 31.03.2023 represented by the thematic sections “economy” and “science and technology”. The research results are as follows. On the basis of GARCH modeling we revealed that sanctions have a negative impact on capitalization of the largest companies in oil and gas, the consumer sector and telecommunications. The news tonality influences companies’ capitalization. We have developed sanctions indices (a minimal index, an expanded index, a maximally expanded index) which allow to assess the extent of sanctions pressure. On the basis of elastic net method we made the conclusion of priority of sentiment variables over the control ones, i.e. information on sanctions and its tonality influences the stock market more than the oil prices, rouble exchange rate and interbank rate in the short term. Sanctions influence is not industry specific.

However, the study does entail certain limitations: 1. reliance on publications from a single source; 2. the use of a single dictionary for evaluating news sentiment; 3. the sanctions index does not allow the incorporation of new terms when fresh sanctions are imposed. We intend to address these issues in future research.

Journal of Corporate Finance Research. 2023;17(2):50-67
pages 50-67 views

Reviews

Determinants of CEO Investment Horizon. A Literature Review

Podukhovich D.

Abstract

This paper conducts a comprehensive literature review of the factors influencing the emergence of the CEO investment horizon problem – a preference for short-term investments over long-term ones. The root cause of this CEO issue, as in-dicated in existing literature, is often attributed to the CEO's personal risk attitude, shaped by factors like age, tenure, and cultural background.
Numerous sources contributing to the short-term investment problem in public companies are described in the current academic literature. Prominent among these determinants are the challenges of quarterly reporting, the association of corporate performance with short-term metrics, market pressures, and the company's specific risk profile. A study by McKinsey & Company, focused on the short horizon problem, demonstrates that companies inclined toward short-term investments exhibit weaker fundamentals and performance. The consulting firm Ernst & Young has introduced the Long-term Orientation Index, offering a basis for cross-country comparison of decision horizons. In 2010, Antia and colleagues introduced a metric for measuring CEO decision horizons, which relies on CEO personal characteristics. Despite these efforts, a comprehensive literature review addressing the specificity of the CEO investment horizon problem and its dis-tinctions from the broader corporate investment horizon problem has been absent.
This paper not only investigates the initial empirical exploration of the short investment horizon problem but also raises questions about its cross-country manifestations, its potential correlation with economic crises, and the relevant personal traits of CEOs for its study. Finally, the paper proposes various strategies to mitigate the CEO investment horizon problem within companies.

Journal of Corporate Finance Research. 2023;17(2):95-109
pages 95-109 views