Vol 17, No 4 (2023)
- Year: 2023
- Articles: 8
- URL: https://journal-vniispk.ru/2073-0438/issue/view/20006
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.17323/j.jcfr.2073-0438.17.4.2023
Full Issue
New Research
Do Mergers and Acquisitions Promote R&D? The Case of European Innovation and Technology sector
Abstract
Innovation efforts and R&D play a foundational role for companies seeking to further develop their products and services and secure a sufficient market share. This is especially relevant for knowledge-intensive fields, particularly for the Innovation and Technology Sector, where players are constantly challenged with adapting to its multi-faceted nature, processing large amounts of data, and rapid innovation transfer. Thus, it is important to study the factors that contribute to R&D intensity and encourage innovations in detail. The study explores the impact of M&A activity on R&D intensity and R&D spending increase of both the acquiring companies and their targets in European Union. The final sample consists of 85 companies that had implemented M&A deals in the Innovation and Technology sector of the EU between 2007 and 2021, acting as acquirers or targets in these deals. The data is collected from Refinitiv Eikon database. Subgroups are determined based on categorization established by the European Commission. These include Business support service activities, Computer programming, Data processing, Manufacturing, and Telecommunications. In addition, financial data was collected on non-merging companies for forming a control group for the analysis. Difference-in-difference and probit model estimation methods are used to analyze the effect of M&A activity on the companies involved. The results show that the R&D intensity of both acquirers and targets decreases in the post-merger period. As for R&D expenditures, they increase for acquiring companies, while the effect is the opposite for their targets. The study contributes to the literature as it, unlike other similar studies that focus mostly on one group of actors, differentiates between the effect on the innovation activity of targets and the effect on the acquirers. The results could be used to increase the knowledge of the M&A effect on innovation efforts in the Innovation and Technology sector in European countries and understanding the possible problems it could lead to.



Corporate Resilience in Cancel Culture Times
Abstract
Corporate resilience has emerged as a prominent focus in international studies, particularly in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic that unfolded in 2019. This attention has been amplified by the structural shifts in the business models of Russian companies, prompted by imposed sanctions, thereby accentuating the need for comprehensive academic exploration of resilience, its driving forces, and adaptive turnaround strategies, especially in the era of cancel culture. Despite the heightened significance of resilience, the drivers underlying it during structural crises remain insufficiently studied. This paper addresses this gap by employing a combination of quantitative methods applied to a sample of publicly traded Russian companies spanning the years 2012 to 2022 (first half), alongside case studies. Our contribution to the literature is manifold. Firstly, our application of Altman’s Z-score model to publicly traded companies unveils the industries with the highest and lowest resilience across the Russian market from a historical perspective. Secondly, we assert that fluctuations in the degree of resilience during turbulent times, as captured by the Z-score, offer a more adequate evaluation compared to popular market-based metrics like total shareholder returns (TSR). Thirdly, our findings reveal that higher credit ratings and state ownership have no evident impact on the degree of resilience. Conversely, the professional background of CEOs is correlated with firm performance and plays a significant role in determining company resilience amid cancel culture challenges.



Performance of M&A Deals in The Russian Market: Evidence from Oil & Gas and Power Industries
Abstract
The paper provides a comprehensive investigation of M&A deals on the Russian market, particularly in the Oil and Gas and Power sectors. This research fills the gap in literature by scrutinizing key M&A trends, reviewing M&A activities, and evaluating M&A performance through a combined application of Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) and case study analysis. A critical part of this study involves exploring the influence of geopolitical factors on these transactions. The article presents a novel academic contribution by offering focused insights on M&A activities in two under-researched yet critical sectors of the Russian economy. Furthermore, the innovative use of DEA and case study analysis enhances our understanding of industry trends over a span of 22 years, including the M&A transactions of 2022. Our sample includes 23 deals made by 17 Russian companies in the Energy and Power industries. We selected deals as a result of which the acquirer companies obtained more than 50% of the target company, so the acquirer company gained control over the operations and performance of the acquired company. The study traces the effects of geopolitical influences on M&A outcomes, a critical consideration given Russia’s unique geopolitical context. This research is of practical significance for domestic and international businesses contemplating M&A decisions within Russia’s Oil & Gas and Power industries, offering valuable insights to guide future strategies. While this study uncovers promising positive trends, further exploration and long-term data are necessary for a complete assessment of the impact of these M&A activities on company performance.



Stakeholder Value Creation through Business Restructuring: Post Sanctions Evidence from Russian Airlines
Abstract
The study is devoted to evaluating of turnaround strategies used by Russian airlines to overcome negative influence of 2022 crisis caused by sanctions pressure of West regulators in terms of ability to create value both for financial and non-financial stakeholders. To conduct a quantitative analysis of the effectiveness of turnaround strategies, evaluation methods based on traditional accounting indicators were used, as well as VBM indicators that take into account an opportunity cost. A qualitative analysis includes the estimation of management actions and decisions in terms of whether they violate interest of companies’ major stakeholders. The study was carried out on the basis of such indicators as: PBITD/CE, PBITD/TD, ROA, Gross margin, EBITDA margin, Net Debt to EBITDA, EVA, Sustainable growth index and Interests harmonized index. As a result of the study, the features of turnaround strategies used by Russian airlines, namely PJSC Utair and LLC Pobeda were studied. The accounting ratios as well as the dynamic of economic profit were evaluated. The Growth sustainability matrix was constructed. The effectiveness of turnaround strategies in terms of value creation both for financial and non-financial stakeholders was assessed and the conclusions about prospects of companies’ further development were made. The above results can be taken into account in the development of more sustainable turnaround strategies by other companies faced with challenges.



How Do Inclusive Growth Practices Affect Financial Performance and the Value of Metallurgy Companies?
Abstract
The article examines inclusive growth practices used in metallurgical companies and assesses their impact on financial results and value. An analysis of data from 102 of the largest companies in the metals industry between 2016 and 2021 showed that reducing greenhouse gas emissions, improving air quality, proper waste disposal, building an inclusive supply chain, respecting human rights and building community relations in the places where the company operates have a positive impact on its financial results and value. The results of the study can be used by top managers of metallurgical companies to formulate an inclusive growth strategy that meets the interests of all stakeholders, which will improve financial results and contribute to the growth of company value.



The Impact of ESG Ratings on Financial Performance of the Companies: Evidence from BRICS Countries
Abstract
Non-financial factors become the relevant topic in the context of understanding the successful development of companies over the world. The purpose of this paper is to study the relationship between ESG scores and financial performance of firms operating in emerging markets, in particular BRICS countries. This study includes three financial performance indicators to cover three different perspectives: accounting measure (ROA), market performance (TSR) and economic metric (EVA spread). The ESG scores, its pillars and other financial metrics are taken from Refinitiv Eikon. The sample consists of 257 listed companies operating in BRICS countries throughout 2017–2021. The main method of the research is the Fixed Effect method for panel data. The results showed that there is no statistical significance between ESG and ROA. Besides, government pillars negatively affect ROA through CSR that is explained by legitimacy theory. As for TSR, ESG, social and environment pillars have positive effects on market performance measure, following stakeholder theory. Regarding economic performance, ESG and social pillar have negative influence on EVA spread.



Dividend Policy of Russian Companies: Cancel Culture Effect
Abstract
The paper is dedicated to the dividend policy of Russian companies under the sanctions pressure applied by the USA and the EU, which especially intensified in 2022 as a result of the changed global geopolitical environment. Cancel culture was used against Russia, complicating the financial, investment and operating activity of domestic companies. In the paper we analyze a sample of 73 Russian listed companies from non-banking sectors and 317 observations for 2017–2022. We consider the impact of sanctions against companies, boards of directors and CEOs on the company dividend policy. We used a logistic regression as a model to determine the probability of influence of changes in the studied variables on the decision concerning dividend payment. The sample is divided into two parts: 2017–2020 and 2021, and it illustrates companies’ behavior when the political environment in the world was stable and when the situation was aggravated. The research showed that sanctions against boards of directors and direct limitations of company’s operations had a negative influence on the probability of dividend payments while sanctions against CEO in the period of aggravation of political risks produced a positive effect. The cancel culture effect, i.e., the refusal of the USA and EU to cooperate with Russia and sanctions imposed on it, produced a significant negative effect on dividend payout by Russian companies.



Reviews
ESG Transformation in the Largest Emerging Capital Market of China. A Literature Review
Abstract
The paper provides a scholarly examination of academic studies of the ESG landscape in China through a systematic literature review with a major focus on the nature and intensity of regulatory guidelines and policies. While many studies indicate positive effects of Chinese ESG policies on corporate ESG performance and investment, they primarily focus on environmental aspects. This analysis of China’s ESG rating system exposes relationships between ESG ratings, corporate performance, financing costs, including both debt and equity financing. The research on equity financing costs is inconsistent and limited in scope, indicating the need for additional investigation. Of the factors influencing ESG, the past year has seen a surge in research on the topic of digital transformation and ESG performance. Most studies demonstrate that digital transformation contributes to ESG performance, and a few suggest that digital transformation positively moderates the effect of ESG performance on firm value enhancement. This review discusses the growth of ESG investment in China, focusing on pension funds, commercial banks, and ESG funds, as well as investor preferences. Despite the growing role of ESG in investment decisions, extant research is largely theoretical, underscoring the need for more empirical and quantitative studies. The research identifies gaps in studies devoted to ESG investment, including the need for comprehensive studies on the impact of ESG across various insurance types and industries, and the development of effective ESG quality assessment methods. This review is among the first academic resources summarizing and integrating various studies, and highlighting areas for future ESG research in China.


