No 1 (2024)
- Year: 2024
- Published: 25.05.2024
- Articles: 17
- URL: https://journal-vniispk.ru/2414-5750/issue/view/24939
Full Issue
Scientific Mentor
Some Problems of Criminal Law Regulation of Liability of Persons Who Committed a Crime Before Reaching the Age of Majority
Abstract
This paper analyzes the current Russian criminal legislation on the legal regulation of the liability of persons who committed a crime before reaching the age of majority. The relevance of the topic lies primarily in the fact that juvenile delinquency is a fertile ground on which adult delinquency is reproduced. For example, according to K. E. Igoshev and G. M. Minkovsky, about 60 percent of persons who committed crimes before the age of majority, then, as adults, continue to commit crimes that subsequently form a recidivism, a dangerous recidivism and a particularly dangerous recidivism. Consequently, the level of success in solving problems in the field of combating crime as a whole is correlated with the measures of preventive and criminal law influence in relation to the age category of the population under consideration.
The objectives of the study are, in particular, the comparative-legal, formal-legal (dogmatic) analysis of the norms of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation (hereinafter referred to as the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation), international legal documents, the Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation of February 1, 2011 No. 1 “On the judicial practice of applying legislation regulating the peculiarities of criminal responsibility and punishment of minors”, the theoretical analysis of scientific works on the topic of this work.
The purpose of the study is to identify problems in the field of criminal law regulation of the liability of persons who committed a crime before reaching the age of majority, and to develop proposals for its improvement.
8-16
On the threshold values of the results of the examination of dissertations in automatic systems for detecting text borrowings
Abstract
In accordance with paragraph 1 of clause 10 of the Regulation on the Procedure for Awarding Academic Degrees, approved by Russian Government Resolution No. 8428 of September 24, 2013 (hereinafter referred to as the Regulation), a dissertation must be independently written by the author, possess internal coherence, contain new scientific results and propositions put forward for public defense, and demonstrate the author's personal contribution to science.
According to clause 14 of the Regulation, in the dissertation, the candidate for an academic degree is required to cite the author and/or the source of borrowed materials or individual results.
When using the results of scientific work completed by the candidate for an academic degree personally and/or in collaboration with others in the dissertation, the candidate for an academic degree is required to note this fact in the dissertation.
17-20
Theory and history of state and law
Legal Doctrine as an Atypical Source of Law
Abstract
Doctrinal legal provisions in Russia are becoming increasingly important in terms of determining the strategy and tactics of legal regulation in the face of new challenges. This is manifested primarily in the consolidation of official doctrines at the level of regulatory legal acts of the President and the Government of the Russian Federation. The purpose of the study is to generate scientific knowledge about the essential properties of legal doctrine. Objectives: to identify the relationship between forms and sources of law; explore the properties of the doctrine as an atypical source of law, its types and forms of manifestation.
Forms and sources of law should be distinguished: the source is the factors that predetermine the content of the rules of law, while the form of law is the external documentary form of expression of the rules of law. Legal doctrine in the Russian Federation manifests itself as official and scientific, while the official doctrine is approved by regulatory legal acts. Legal doctrine, primarily official, acts in Russia as an atypical source of law, increasingly influencing the content of legal regulation. Its legal force has not yet been fully determined.
21-28
Administrative law
Problems of Applying Administrative Liability in Relation to Foreign Citizens
Abstract
The article analyzes the legislation regulating the administrative responsibility of foreign citizens. The main problems related to the application of administrative responsibility to foreigners, such administrative penalties as an administrative fine applied to foreign citizens subject to expulsion, administrative expulsion and deportation of foreign citizens outside the Russian Federation, where attention was focused on the difference between these concepts. Also the problem of providing legal assistance to foreign citizens was identified, where The problems that a lawyer may face were listed, in this regard, ways to solve problems were proposed and proposals were developed to improve legislation in this area.
29-36
Civil law
Features of Legal Regulation of Relations Related to the Conclusion of a License Agreement Granting the Right to use a Computer Program
Abstract
This article presents the results of an analysis of legislation and law enforcement practice related to the license agreement granting the right to use a computer program. Certain types of licenses and their characteristic features are considered, the most important principles of legal regulation of license agreements are described based on the study of foreign regulations and judicial practice on this issue. Particular attention is paid to the principle of dichotomy of ideas and their expressions, as well as the practice of their differentiation. Based on the results of the study, it is concluded that it is advisable to study the experience of litigation on this issue in foreign countries.
37-45
Legal Protection of Computer Programs in Business Activities Through Patenting
Abstract
The article raises the question of the possibility of protecting computer programs through patenting. The expediency of applying patent protection to a computer program is considered both from a theoretical point of view and from the point of view of Russian legislation. A comparative analysis of the patent protection regime with copyright law is carried out, and the advantages of protecting the first along with the simpler requirements of the second are highlighted. The content of the technical solution is disclosed, in which the computer program for the application of patent regimes should be expressed. Examples of software protection through patenting are given. It is proposed to consolidate the concept of a computer program and the conditions under which a computer program becomes patentable, revealing the concept of a technical solution and a functional component.
46-58
Civil liability of a Person Exercising the Powers of the Sole Executive Body
Abstract
The article raises the issue of bringing a person exercising the powers of the sole executive body of management in a business company to civil liability. This problem remains relevant at the present time, since in judicial practice there are a large number of cases in which the general director is held accountable, including in the case of instructions (with the consent) of higher management bodies of a legal entity. The paper presents the main provisions and options for solving this issue. The result of the study was the formulation of conditions for bringing certain individuals to civil liability, and also a conclusion was made about the significance of the circumstances of the case, which indicate dishonest and (or) unreasonable actions (inaction) of the director.
59-64
Legal Regulation of Relations in the use of Cloud Technologies in the Russian Federation
Abstract
Cloud technologies have become an increasingly common way of storing, processing and transferring data in the modern world. The paper analyzes the problems and challenges associated with the application of legal norms to cloud technologies in Russia, including the ambiguity of definitions and concepts, the possible contradiction between the requirements of legislation and the technical features of cloud platforms, as well as the need to comply with the requirements for the protection of the rights of personal data subjects. The object of the study is the relations arising from the use of cloud technologies, an assessment of the advantages, problems with defining terms and concluding contracts in the field of cloud technologies is carried out. The article identified shortcomings that may require further changes and clarifications in the legislation. This study may allow to create a more effective and balanced system of legal protection when using cloud technologies in the Russian Federation.
65-71
Redistribution of capital within the holding company: implementation of the “Rozenblum test” in Russian legislation
Abstract
In this paper, consider: the role of the economic interest of the participants of corporate groups (holdings); the opposition of the economic interests of the minority and majority participants of the corporation; the responsibility of the directors of subsidiaries of legal entities for transactions within the holding. The legal issues of the study involve the analysis of the legal regulation of corporate governance and control in holdings, the search for a balance to protect the rights and interests of the corporation’s participants. To estimate the need of developing the criteria for recognizing the group-wide interest of holding companies and standards for protecting the rights of minority shareholders, the mechanisms of legal regulation of these legal relations in the legislation of European Union countries and foreign scientific sources were considered.
It is concluded that Russian doctrine and judicial practice recognize a group-wide economic interest, but do not contain established criteria for its recognition. In turn, the consolidation of these standards used to protect the rights of minority shareholders would improve the level of corporate governance in corporate groups and prevent unfair infringement of the rights of majority shareholders.
72-81
Information Law
Formation of Digital Legal Awareness Among Young People: From Scoring to Social Networks of Public Authorities
Abstract
The article is devoted to the study of the peculiarities of the formation of digital legal awareness among young people in the modern period of development of society, as well as the factors influencing this process. The content of the concept of “digital legal awareness” is analyzed. Attention is focused on the aspect of the need to form and develop consumer and user culture of citizens of the Russian Federation as an integral part of legal awareness, and through this prism the development of the scoring system in Russia is analyzed. It is noted that such a perception model as clip thinking is most characteristic of the youth environment. Attention is also drawn to the fact that social networks have a great influence on the formation of digital legal awareness, a distinctive feature of maintaining pages in which is the brevity, accessibility, and content of the transmitted information that correspond to clip thinking. It is emphasized that the mandatory maintenance of pages of state bodies, local governments, subordinate organizations and courts in social networks, the purpose of which is the development of digital legal awareness of citizens, may become an urgent area for the professional development of a number of young professionals. It is concluded that the formation of digital legal awareness is carried out in different directions, in different ways, on different platforms, being one of the most important issues of our time.
82-87
Financial law
Countering Illegal Methods of Tax Optimization by the Example of Internet Bloggers
Abstract
Tax optimization within the limits set by law allows taxpayers to reduce the amount of taxes paid, but taxpayers often use methods and techniques of illegal tax optimization, resulting in underestimation of the tax base and incomplete payment of taxes. This is evidenced by the increasing number of reports in the media about the institution of criminal proceedings against Internet bloggers under Article 198 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation for non-payment of taxes. Detection of facts of illegal tax optimization – understatement of the tax base under the simplified taxation system in relation to Internet bloggers – is most often connected with the fragmentation of business and withdrawal of funds to an account in foreign banks. As the market for information services is rapidly developing, tax administration methods that allow automatic tracking of sites and transactions of large Internet bloggers should also be rapidly developed. In this case, data collected automatically should be compared with accounting data. The mechanisms of tax optimization used by Internet bloggers are analyzed to propose ways and methods of counteracting them.
88-94
Civil and Administrative Procedure
Special Powers of Proxy in Arbitration Procedure
Abstract
The article draws attention to the special powers of proxy representatives in the arbitration procedure. At the moment there are some restrictions in the legislation in connection with the political situation in the country, in particular, concerning the problem of recovery of funds by foreign organizations through the representative’s bank account. In this article the author draws attention to the innovations in the Federal Law of October 2, 2007 No. 229-FZ “On Enforcement Proceedings”, as well as to the court practice developed during the amendments. The conclusion of the article summarizes the fact that the current practice is contrary to the law and also puts the parties to the process in an unequal position, in this regard some amendments should be made that will clarify the provisions, concerning special credentials of representatives.
95-102
Features of the Proof Process in Cases of Invalidation of Transactions and the Application of the Consequences of Invalidity of Transactions in the Field of Family Relations
Abstract
This article examines the problems of the proof process in cases related to the recognition of transactions as invalid and the application of the consequences of their invalidity in the field of family relations. The problem of such a concept as an “extremely unfavorable position” when recognizing a marriage contract as invalid is also revealed.
This article reveals the process of proving cases of invalidation of transactions and the application of the consequences of invalidity of transactions in the field of family relations. The analysis of the evidence that should be provided to the parties to such a dispute in the process is carried out, such categories as the subject of proof, the distribution of the burden of proof, and remedies for both the plaintiff and the defendant (for example, filing a counterclaim) are also considered. The analysis of judicial practice has been carried out, showing the problem of the evaluation category “extremely unfavorable situation” as grounds for invalidating a marriage contract, and therefore, it is concluded that there is no uniformity in the assessment of circumstances in this category of cases.
Within the framework of the conducted research, it is determined that in the field of consideration of cases on invalidation of transactions and the application of the consequences of invalidity of transactions in the field of family relations it seems necessary to bring judicial practice to a uniform application of legal norms, since this seems to be a problem both for persons involved in the process and for the courts.
103-114
Criminal Procedure and Forensic Science
Ensuring the Rights of Minors Accused in Criminal Proceedings
Abstract
The social and age immaturity of adolescents who commit crimes requires special rules for criminal proceedings against minors. The differentiated form of proceedings in such cases is based on additional guarantees of ensuring the rights of criminally prosecuted minors. The published results of scientific research on the problems of ensuring the rights of persons in respect of whom proceedings are being conducted according to the rules determined by Chapter 50 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of the Russian Federation were taken as a theoretical basis for this article.
The article identifies the main features of ensuring the rights of minors in Russian criminal procedure. The author makes proposals for improving criminal procedural legislation. It is concluded that modern Russian criminal procedure have been able to implement the basic standards of child-friendly justice, but still it is necessary to clarify the content of individual criminal procedural norms in order to ensure uniform law enforcement practice.
115-121
Actual Problems of Sentencing in Absentia in Criminal Cases
Abstract
The trial without the participation of the defendant, enshrined in the Code of Criminal Procedure of the Russian Federation, causes discussions due to the presence of legislative gaps. In the doctrine, proposals to improve the institution of sentencing in absentia were put forward by V. V. Seroshtan, A. Yu. Klyuchnikov, D. T. Arabuli and other processualists. As a result of scientific research, the author identified the main problems associated with the implementation of the institute of correspondence proceedings, and proposes measures to eliminate them. Problems such as the absence of a legally fixed list of exceptional cases, the absence of the duty of the investigator, the court to clarify the defendant’s right to petition for consideration of a criminal case in his absence, the implementation of the principle of competition and some other problems are highlighted. It is concluded that the trial in absentia in a criminal case needs legislative revision, because some provisions of this institution are insufficiently regulated and contradictory.
122-128
Language and Law
The Use of Profanity in Procedural Documents as a Legal Linguistic Problem
Abstract
The authors consider the possibility of introducing obscene expressions into the text of the interrogation protocol, which is a zone of intersection of language and law. The article analyzes Russian legislation and judicial practice concerning the use of profanity in procedural documentation. The authors come to the conclusion that it is impossible to use profanity in official procedural documents and draw attention to the need to regulate the procedure for excluding (replacing) profanity in order to avoid falsification of the results of investigative actions and in order to solve problems arising at the intersection of language and law, which are the main promising task of legal linguistics.
129-136
The Definition of a Good Name as a Problem of Legal Linguistics
Abstract
The article is dedicated to the lingua- and legal-based analysis the concept of “good name” from the point of view of linguistics and jurisprudence. The article reveals contradictions between the concepts of “good name” and “business reputation” in the legal language due to the lack of clarity of legislative norms. The author concludes that it is necessary to clarify and further develop the legislative framework for a more precise definition and protection of the rights of subjects in the context of their image and reputation. The emphasis is on the need to harmonize legal and linguistic aspects in understanding and protecting a good name, which contributes to ensuring justice and legality.
137-142

