Infinite loss: jealousy and love in mimetic theory
- Authors: Grigoryeva E.1,2
-
Affiliations:
- Lomonosov Moscow State University
- Institute of Scientific Information for Social Sciences (INION RAS)
- Issue: Vol 34, No 5 (2024)
- Pages: 87-114
- Section: TOWARDS THE PROBLEM OF MIMETICISM
- URL: https://journal-vniispk.ru/0869-5377/article/view/291432
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.17323/0869-5377-2024-5-87-112
- ID: 291432
Cite item
Abstract
The article proposes consideration of the situation of infinite loss within the framework of René Girard’s triangle of mimetic mechanism that includes a loving subject, the object of his love and a model that acts as an obstacle to the desire of the subject. In the described configuration, jealousy is constitutive for the subject: without continuous looking back at the model or, in other words, at the ideal Other, love is impossible. The one to whom the subject loses his own love game becomes the one in relation to whom he ascribes to himself a radical insufficiency. The desire of the subject here becomes the obsession with the ideal Other or the mediator of desire — the one who prevents the subject from reaching the object of his love and the one who provides jealousy with his appearance.
In addition to the Girard’s philosophy and its interpretation by Jean-Pierre Dupuis, the author of the article bases his concept of endless loss on the works of Merab Mamardashvili, Paul Preciado, Alenka Zupančič, Jacques Lacan, Georges Bataille, Otto Rank, Michel Leiris, Alain Badiou, Franz Kafka. As the main illustrative material, the article considers the Black Swan movie by Darren Aronofsky, which describes the situation of endless loss in the mimetic theory. The mediator of desire here simultaneously becomes the mirror double of the subject, thereby radicalizing the intuition of imitation within the framework of the mimetic triangle. Desire appears as impossible and unattainable, since the elimination of duality turns out to be a suicidal act, and the appearance of winning invariably turns into a loss. The possibility of getting out of the described triangle of imitation and loss is problematized on the material of Marcel Proust’s The End of Jealousy and is associated by the author with the theme of death.
Keywords
Full Text

About the authors
Ekaterina Grigoryeva
Lomonosov Moscow State University; Institute of Scientific Information for Social Sciences (INION RAS)
Author for correspondence.
Email: yatak.grig@yandex.ru
Russian Federation, Moscow; Moscow
References
- Badiou A. Etika: Ocherk o soznanii Zla [L’éthique: Essai sur la conscience du mal], St. Petersburg, Machina, 2006.
- Bakhtin M. M. Avtor i geroi. K filosofskim osnovam gumanitarnykh nauk [Author and Hero. To the Philosophical Foundations of the Humanities], St. Petersburg, Azbooka, 2000.
- Bataille G. Nevozmozhnoe [L’Impossible]. Nenavist’ k poezii: Romany i povesti [Haine de la poésie], Moscow, Ladomir, 2017, pp. 223–304.
- Bataille G., Peignot C. Sakral’noe [Le Sacré], Tver, Kolonna Publications, 2010.
- Blanchot M. Prostranstvo literatury [L’Espace littéraire], Moscow, Logos, 2002.
- Deleuze G. Marsel’ Prust i znaki [Marcel Proust et les signes], St. Petersburg, Aleteia, 2017.
- Dolar M. “Dvoinik” Otto Ranka [Otto Rank und der Doppelgänger]. In: Rank O. Dvoinik [Der Doppelgänger. Eine psychoanalytische Studie], St. Petersburg, Skifiia-print, 2017.
- Dolar M., Bozovic M., Zupančič A. Liubovnaia mashina. Lakan i Spinoza. Komediia liubvi [The Love Machine. Lacan and Spinoza. The Comedy of Love], St. Petersburg, Aleteia, 2020.
- Girard R. Lozh’ romantizma i pravda romana [Mensonge romantique et verité romanesque], Moscow, New Literary Observer, 2019.
- Girard R. Teatr zavisti. Uil’iam Shekspir [Shakespeare: les feux de l’envie], Moscow, St. Andrew’s Publishing House, 2021.
- Kafka F. Amerika. Protsess. Iz dnevnikov [Amerika. Der Prozeß. Tagebücher], Moscow, Politizdat, 1991.
- Kristeva J. Chernoe solntse: Depressiia i melankholiia [Soleil noir. Depression et melancolie], Moscow, Cogito-Centre, 2010.
- Leiris M. Vozrast muzhchiny [L’Age d’homme], St. Petersburg, Nauka, 2002.
- Mamardashvili M. K. Estetika myshleniia [Aesthetics of Thinking]. Filosofskie chteniia [Philosophical Readings], St. Petersburg, Azbooka-klassika, 2002, pp. 173–489.
- Mamardashvili M. K. Lektsii o Pruste (psikhologicheskaia topologiia puti) [Psychological Topology of Path (Lectures on Proust)], Moscow, Ad Marginem, 1995.
- Merleau-Ponty M. Fenomenologiia vospriiatiia [Phenomenologie de la Perception], St. Petersburg, Iuventa, Nauka, 1999.
- Podoroga V. A. Mimesis. Materialy po analiticheskoi antropologii literatury [Mimesis: The Analytic Anthropology of Literature], Moscow, Cultural revolution, 2006.
- Preciado P. B. Ia vliublen [Je suis amoureux]. Telegraph, October 25, 2022. Available at: https://telegra.ph/YA-vlyublen-10-25.
- Proust M. Konets revnosti [La fin de la jalousie]. Utekhi i dni [Les plaisirs et les jours], Moscow, Ripol-classic, 2018, pp. 75–83.
- Rey O. Glubinnye prostranstva zhelaniia [L’arrière-pays du désir]. In: Dupuy J.-P. Revnost’. Geometriia zhelaniia [La jalousie. Une géométrie du désir], St. Petersburg, Ivan Limbakh Publishing House, 2021, pp. 215–261.
- Smulyansky A. Zhelanie oderzhimogo: nevroz naviazchivosti v lakanovskoi teorii [The Desire of the Obsessive: Compulsion Neurosis in Lacanian Theory], 2nd ed., St. Petersburg, Aleteia, 2018.
- Zupančič A. Povtoriaia konets [Repeating the End]. Lacanalia, 2019, no. 32, p. 6–21. Available at: http://www.lacan.ru/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/Lakanaliya-Vremya.pdf.
- Zupančič A. The Odd One In: On Comedy (Short Circuits), Cambridge, MA, MIT Press, 2009.
Supplementary files
