On scientific and non-scientific criticism: reflections on the margins of reviews
- 作者: Ganin A.V.1, Goldin V.I.2
-
隶属关系:
- Institute of Slavic Studies of the Russian Academy of Sciences
- Northern (Arctic) Federal University named after M.V. Lomonosov
- 期: 编号 1 (2025)
- 页面: 51-63
- 栏目: HISTORY
- URL: https://journal-vniispk.ru/2072-3024/article/view/295914
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.21685/2072-3024-2025-1-5
- ID: 295914
如何引用文章
全文:
详细
Background. The article is devoted to the analysis of the works of the famous historian, chief researcher of the Institute of Russian History of the Russian Academy of Sciences V.P. Buldakov, which can be classified as unscientific. The relevance of the work is determined by the need to respond objectively to historiographical challenges. Materials and methods. The works of V.P. Buldakov of the Soviet and post-Soviet periods are stud-ied. An overview of the methods used to conduct polemics with opponents is given. Some specific historical subjects that have become the subject of discussion are considered. First of all, the question of assessing the chronological framework and nature of the Civil Warand foreign military intervention. Results. The array of works by V.P. Buldakov is analyzed, their characteristics are given, some historiographical errors are debunked. Conclusions. The unscientific nature of the polemic conducted by V.P. Buldakov with his opponents is shown.
作者简介
Andrey Ganin
Institute of Slavic Studies of the Russian Academy of Sciences
编辑信件的主要联系方式.
Email: andrey_ganin@mail.ru
Doctor of historical sciences, leading researcher
(32A Leninskiy avenue, Moscow, Russia)Vladislav Goldin
Northern (Arctic) Federal University named after M.V. Lomonosov
Email: v.i.goldin@yandex.ru
Doctor of historical sciences, professor, professor of the sub- department of regional studies, international relations and political sciences
(2 Lomonosova avenue, Arkhangelsk, Russia)参考
- Buldakov V.P. Historiographical window dressing. Notes on the book “Between the canons. Historical research in Russia over the last 25 Years” (edited by G.A. Bordyu-gov. M.: AIRO-XXI, 2013). Vestnik Tverskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya: Istoriya = Bulletin of Tver State University. Series: History. 2016;(2):125–141. (In Russ.)
- Buldakov V.P. The Historiographical confusion of our days. On the book by E.Yu. Se-menov “The Russian city during the years of the First World War (by the materials from the Volga Region)”. Samara, 2016. 198 p. Vestnik Tverskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya: Istoriya = Bulletin of Tver State University. Series: History. 2018;(2):114–130. (In Russ.)
- Buldakov V.P. The Fruits of Methodological Helplessness. About the Book by A.V. Ganin “Seven reasons of the Russian Civil War” (Moscow: Izd-vo “Pyatyy Rim” (OOO “Best-seller”), 2018. 864 s., il.). Vestnik Tverskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya: Is-toriya = Bulletin of Tver State University. Series: History. 2019;(1):125–141. (In Russ.)
- Buldakov V.P. Bezhentsy The first world and their modern researchers. About the book by N.V. Surzhikovoy, N.A. Mikhalev, S.A. P’yankov “Russian Bezhenstvo: Centers and Peripheries, Processes and Structures, Individuals and Masses (1914–1922)”. Yeka-terinburg; Chelyabinsk: Izdatel′skiy tsentr YUUrGU, 2021. 493 s. Vestnik Tverskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya: Istoriya = Bulletin of Tver State University. Se-ries: History. 2022;(3):135–145. (In Russ.)
- Buldakov V.P. Historian and elder brother of the political state (Khutarev-Garnishevskiy V. V. Counter-Strike. Special services, army and state on the Eve of the Fall of the Russian Empire, 1913–1917). M.: Izd-vo Instituta Gaydara, 2020. 648 s.). Vestnik Tverskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya: Istoriya = Bulletin of Tver State University. Series: History. 2023;(4):171–179. (In Russ.)
- Buldakov V.P. On the origin of historiographic absurdities. Vestnik Tverskogo gosudar-stvennogo universiteta. Seriya: Istoriya = Bulletin of Tver State University. Series: His-tory. 2024;(3):155–167. (In Russ.)
- Mironov B.N. Strasti po revolyutsii: Nravy v rossiyskoy istoriografii v vek informatsii. 2-e izd. = Passions for the revolution: morals in Russian historiography in the infor-mation age. The 2nd edition. Moscow: Ves′ mir, 2014:336. (In Russ.)
- Malen′kiy chelovek i bol′shaya voyna v istorii Rossii: seredina XIX – seredina XX v.: materialy Mezhdunar. kollokviuma (g. Sankt-Peterburg, 17–20 iyunya 2013 g.) = The little man and the Great War in Russian history: Mid-20th – Mid-20th century: Proceedings of the International Colloquium. Saint Petersburg: Nestor-istoriya, 2015:572. (In Russ.)
- Ioffe G.Z. Chetvertaya volna = The fourth wave. Moscow: Kalligraf, 2012:141. (In Russ.)
- Ioffe G.Z. World War I and the Russian Revolution of 1917. Nauka i zhizn′ = Science and life. 2014;(11):26–35. (In Russ.)
- Ioffe G.Z. Inyye vremena. Vospominaniya = Other times. Memories. Moscow: Filobib-lon, 2015:324. (In Russ.)
- god v Yevrazii = 1917 in Eurasia. Moscow: [B.i.], 2017:600. (In Russ.)
- Goldin V.I. Sever Rossii na puti k Grazhdanskoy voyne: Popytki reform. Revolyutsii. Mezhdunarodnaya interventsiya. 1900 – leto 1918 = The Russian North on the road to Civil War: Attempts at reform. Revolutions. International intervention. 1900 – Summer 1918. Arkhangel′sk: SAFU, 2018:619. (In Russ.)
- Buldakov V.P. Krasnaya smuta: Priroda i posledstviya revolyutsionnogo nasiliya. 2-e izd., dop. = Red troubles: the nature and consequences of revolutionary violence. The 2nd edi-tion, revised and supplemented. Moscow: ROSSPEN, 2010:967. (In Russ.)
- Vo imya nauki – na blago Otechestva = In the name of science – for the benefit of the Fatherland. Arkhangel′sk: SAFU, 2016:245. (In Russ.)
- Goldin V.I. Na perekrestkakh pamyati = At the crossroads of memory. Arkhangel′sk: SAFU, 2021:495. (In Russ.)
- Zhizn′, polnaya smysla = A life full of meaning. Arkhangel′sk: Lotsiya, 2021:298. (In Russ.)
- Live, learning about the world. Vuzovskiy vestnik (Moskva) = University bulletin (Mos-cow). 2021;(15–16):4–5. (In Russ.)
- Buldakov V.P. “Legal Marxism” and the evolution of bourgeois liberal ideology in Russia: PhD abstract. Moscow, 1975:22. (In Russ.)
- Buldakov V.P., Kuleshov S.V. Istoriya obrazovaniya SSSR i kritika yeye fal′si-fikatorov: monografiya = History of the formation of the USSR and criticism of its file’sifiers: monograph. Moscow: Vysshaya shkola, 1982:176. (In Russ.)
- Buldakov V.P., Mikhaylov I.V. The October revolution: towards a critique of the methodological foundations of non-Marxist historiography. Sovremennaya zarubezh-naya nemarksistskaya istoriografiya: Kriticheskiy analiz = Contemporary foreign non-Marxist historiography: Critical analysis. Moscow: Nauka, 1989:347–368. (In Russ.)
- Burganov A., Buldakov V., Bukharayev V. Krasnyy Oktyabr′: dvulikaya istoriya = Red October: a two-faced history. Kazan: Biblioteka zhurnala «Kazan′», 1992:64. (In Russ.)
- Buldakov V.P. Krasnaya smuta. Priroda i posledstviya revolyutsionnogo nasiliya = Red Troubles. The nature and consequences of revolutionary violence. Moscow: ROSSPEN, 1997:376. (In Russ.)
- Liseytsev D.V. (resp. ed.). Istoriya Rossii: v 20 t. T. 5: Rossiya v XVII veke. Kn. 1: Ros-siyskoye gosudarstvo v pervoy polovine XVII veka. 1598–1645 gody = History of Rus-sia: in 20 volumes. Volume 5: Russia in the 17th century. Book 1: Russian State in the first half of the 17th century. 1598–1645. Moscow: Nauka, 2024:770. (In Russ.)
- Grazhdanskaya voyna v Rossii: vzglyad cherez 100 let. Problemy istorii i istoriografii = The Civil War in Russia: a view 100 Years Later. Issues of history and historiography. Saint Petersburg: LETI, 2018:407. (In Russ.)
- Ivanov A.A. Intervention by invitation: the Russian experience. Sovremennyye nauchnyye issledovaniya i innovatsii = Modern scientific research and innovation. 2013;(8). (In Russ.). Available at: https://web.snauka.ru/issues/2013/08/26093 (accessed 07.11.2024).
- Goldin V.I. Anatomiya interventsii, ili Kto i kak razvyazal Grazhdanskuyu voynu na Se-vere Rossii: monografiya = Anatomy of intervention, or Who and how unleashed the Civil War in the North of Russia: monograph. Moscow: Kuchkovo pole, 2024:480. (In Russ.)
- Goldin V.I. Rossiya v grazhdanskoy voyne. Ocherki noveyshey istoriografii (vtoraya polovina 1980-kh – 90-e gody) = Russia in the Civil War. Essays on the newest histori-ography (second half of the 1980s – 90s). Arkhangel′sk: Borges, 2000:277. (In Russ.)
- Goldin V.I. Grazhdanskaya voyna v Rossii skvoz′ prizmu let: istoriograficheskiye protsessy = The Civil War in Russia through the prism of years: historiographic pro-cesses. Murmansk: MGGU, 2012:333. (In Russ.)
- Goldin V.I. Arkticheskaya zhemchuzhina imperii. Russkiy Sever v epokhu reform, revolyutsiy i Pervoy mirovoy voyny = Arctic Pearl of the Empire. Russian North in the age of reforms, revolution and World War I. Moscow: Veche, 2022:445. (In Russ.)
- Ganin A.V. Posledniye dni generala Selivacheva = The Last Days of General Selivachev. Moscow: Kuchkovo pole, 2012:320. (In Russ.)
- Ganin A.V. «Mozg armii» v period «Russkoy Smuty»: st. i dok. = “The brain of the army” during the “Russian Time of Troubles”: articles and reports. Moscow: Russkiy put′, 2013:880. (In Russ.)
- Ganin A.V. B′′lgarin′′t zashchitil Rusiya. S′′dbata na Yordan Pekhlivanov. Sofiya: Milena-print, 2014:114.
- Ganin A.V. Zakat Nikolayevskoy voyennoy akademii 1914–1922 = The decline of the Nikolaev Military Academy 1914–1922. Moscow: Knizhnitsa, 2014:768. (In Russ.)
- Ganin A.V. Povsednevnaya zhizn′ genshtabistov pri Lenine i Trotskom = Everyday life of the General Staff officers under Lenin and Trotsky. Moscow: Kuchkovo pole, 2016:680. (In Russ.)
- Ganin A.V. Povsednevnaya zhizn′ genshtabistov pri Lenine i Trotskom. 2-e izd., ispr. = Everyday life of the General Staff officers under Lenin and Trotsky. The 2nd edition, re-vised. Moscow: Kuchkovo pole, 2017:680. (In Russ.)
- Ganin A.V. Sem′ «pochemu» rossiyskoy Grazhdanskoy voyny = Seven reasons of the Russian Civil War. Moscow: Pyatyy Rim (OOO «Bestseller»), 2018:864. (In Russ.)
- Ganin AV. Ofitserskiy korpus v gody Grazhdanskoy voyny v Rossii. 1917–1922 gg. = Officer corps during the Russian Civil War. 1917–1922. Moscow: Staraya Basmannaya, 2018:272. (In Russ.)
- Ganin A.V. Russkiy ofitserskiy korpus v gody Grazhdanskoy voyny. Protivostoyaniye ko-mandnykh kadrov. 1917–1922 gg. = Russian officer corps during the Civil War. Confronta-tion of command personnel. 1917–1922. Moscow: Tsentrpoligraf, 2019:318. (In Russ.)
- Ganin A.V. Izmena komandarmov. Predstaviteli vysshego komandnogo sostava Kras-noy armii, pereshedshiye na storonu protivnika v gody Grazhdanskoy voyny v Rossii 1917–1922 gg. = Treason of army commanders. Representatives of the Red Army’s high command who came over to the enemy’s side during the Russian Civil War 1917–1922. Moscow: Pyatyy Rim, 2020:800. (In Russ.)
- Ganin A.V. Belyy general i krasnyy voyenspets Yakov Slashchev-Krymskiy = White General and Red Military Specialist Yakov Slashchev-Krymsky. Moscow: Russkiye Vityazi, 2021:256. (In Russ.)
- Ganin A.V. Svoј meђu tuђima i tuђ meђu svoјima. Sudbina ruskog ofitsira i jugo-slovenskog generala Fjodora Makhina. Beograd: Yevoluta, 2021:448.
- Ganin A.V. Voyenspetsy. Ocherki o byvshikh ofitserakh, stoyavshikh u istokov Krasnoy armii = Military Specialists. Essays on former officers who stood at the origins of the Red Army. Moscow: Kuchkovo pole, 2022:768. (In Russ.)
- Ganin A.V. 50 ofitserov. Geroi, antigeroi i zhertvy na istoricheskom perelome 1917–1922 gg. = 50 Officers. Heroes, antiheroes and victims at the historical turning point of 1917–1922. Moscow: Kuchkovo pole Muzeon: Voyevoda, 2022:704. (In Russ.)
- Ganin A.V. Belyy agent pri Staline. Zhizn′ i bor′ba generala Nosovicha = White agent under Stalin. Life and struggle of general nosovich. Moscow: Kuchkovo pole Muzeon, 2022:560. (In Russ.)
- Ganin A.V. Kadry General′nogo shtaba v period Grazhdanskoy voyny v Rossii 1917–1922 gg.: v 2 t. = Personnel of the General Staff during the Russian Civil War 1917–1922: in 2 volumes. Moscow: Kuchkovo pole Muzeon, 2023;1:1000, 2:968. (In Russ.)
- Inostrantsev M.A. Vospominaniya. Konets imperii, revolyutsiya i nachalo bol′shevizma = Memories. The end of the empire, revolution and the beginning of bolshevism. Moscow: Kuchkovo pole: Voyevoda, 2017:928. (In Russ.)
- Shchepikhin S.A. Sibirskiy Ledyanoy pokhod. Vospominaniya = Siberian Ice march. Memories. Moscow: Svyaz′ epokh: Voyevoda, 2020:512. (In Russ.)
- Nosovich A.L. Belyy agent v Krasnoy armii: vospominaniya, dokumenty, stat′i = White agent in the Red Army: memoirs, documents, articles. Moscow; Saint Petersburg: Nes-tor-istoriya, 2021:576. (In Russ.)
- Tseytlin V.M. Dnevnik shtabs-kapitana. 1914–1918 = Diary of a staff captain. 1914–1918. Moscow: Svyaz′ epokh: Voyevoda, 2021:351. (In Russ.)
- Ganin A.V. (ed.) Yuzhnaya armiya Vostochnogo fronta admirala Kolchaka: Vospo-minaniya, dokumenty i materialy = Southern Army of the Eastern Front of Admiral Kol-chak: Memories, documents and materials. Moscow: Nestor-istoriya, 2022:480. (In Russ.)
- Shchepikhin S.A. Vospominaniya 1918–1920 gg. = Memories 1918–1920. Moscow: Svyaz′ epokh, 2024:976. (In Russ.)
补充文件
