Email this article Property Rights as Subjective Civil Rights
- Authors: Ryabzin R.A.1
-
Affiliations:
- Supreme Court of the Russian Federation
- Issue: Vol 17, No 7 (2024)
- Pages: 57-66
- Section: Private Law (Civil) Sciences
- URL: https://journal-vniispk.ru/2072-3164/article/view/284098
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.33693/2072-3164-2024-17-7-057-066
- EDN: https://elibrary.ru/GVKRFH
- ID: 284098
Cite item
Open Access
Access granted
Subscription Access
Abstract
The article is devoted to the analysis of the legal category of property rights, considered as subjective civil rights. The author focuses on the study of the general category of subjective civil rights. It is noted that the prevailing point of view in the doctrine is the understanding of subjective civil rights as a measure of possible (permissible) behavior of an authorized person. However, this is not the only position of scientists. In particular, many scientists reveal the legal nature of the concept under consideration through the possibility of demanding certain behavior from an obligated person, the possibility of using a mechanism of state coercion in case of non-fulfillment by an obligated person and the possibility of an authorized person using a certain social good on the basis of subjective civil law belonging to him.
The article highlights the doctrinal discussions about the possibility of the existence of subjective law "outside the legal relationship", as well as the criteria for distinguishing absolute and relative legal relations.
As a result of the conducted research, the author formulated the following theoretical definition of property subjective rights, which are proposed to be understood as a means of satisfying the property need (interest) of an authorized person, by its legal nature expressed in the possibility of a person's behavior secured and protected by the norms of objective law in relation to the object of subjective civil law (in absolute legal relations) or in relation to a third person (in legal relations of obligations).
Full Text
##article.viewOnOriginalSite##About the authors
Roman A. Ryabzin
Supreme Court of the Russian Federation
Author for correspondence.
Email: rodinzonrom@mail.ru
Cand.Sci.(Law), Judge
Russian Federation, MoscowReferences
- Karger K. Zwangsrechte: Ein Beitrag zur Sustematisierung der Rechte. Berlin, 1882.
- Wolter A. Prawo cywilne. Zarys czesci ogolnej. Warszawa, 1967.
- Adamovich G. Problems of applying the institute of abuse of law in joint-stock legal relations // Economy and law. 2005. No. 5. pp. 58-66.
- Alexandrov N.G. Legality and legal relations in Soviet society. M., 1955. 176 p.
- Alekseev S.S. The mechanism of legal regulation in a socialist state. M., 1966. 187 p.
- Annenkov K.N. The system of Russian civil law. 2nd ed., revised and supplemented by St. Petersburg: Type by M.M. Stasyulevich, 1899. Vol. 1: Introduction and general part. 672 p.
- Belov V.A. Civil law. M., 2002. 622 p.
- Bogatyrev F.O. Interest in civil law // Journal of Russian Law. No. 2. 2002 // SPS "ConsultantPlus".
- Braginsky M.I., Vitryansky V.V. Contractual law: General provisions. M., 1997. 847 p.
- Bratus S.N. Subjects of civil law. M., 1950. 368 p.
- Vavilin E.V. Implementation and protection of civil rights. Moscow: Walters Kluwer, 2009. 360 p.
- Vavilin E.V. Subjective civil law and its implementation // The Power of Law. 2015. No. 1. pp. 43-51.
- Verin A.Yu. On the issue of the structure of the legal status of an individual // Bulletin of Economics, Law and Sociology. 2012. No. 2. pp. 113-115.
- Voishvillo E.K., Degtyarev M.G. Logic as part of the theory of cognition and scientific methodology. Fundamental course: In 2 books. Book II. M., 1994. 333 p.
- Gorsky D.P. Definition (logical and methodological problems). M., 1974. 311 p.
- Volkov A.V. Theory of the concept of "abuse of civil rights". Volgograd: Stanitsa-2, 2007. 352 p.
- Gambarov Y.S. Course of civil law. Vol. 1. General part. St. Petersburg., 1911. 780 p.
- Genkin D.M. The right of ownership in the USSR. M., 1961. 223 p.
- Civil law // Edited by A.P. Sergeev, Y.K. Tolstoy. M., 1996. Part 1. 600 p.
- Gribanov V.P. Interest in civil law // Implementation and protection of civil rights. Moscow: Statute, 2000. 411 p.
- Gribanov V.P. Implementation and protection of civil rights. M., 2001. 414 p.
- Gribanov V.P. Limits of the exercise and protection of civil rights. M., 1972. 283 p.
- Grigorieva M.A. The concept of freedom in Russian civil law. Krasnodar, 2004.
- Ghukasyan R.E. The problem of interest in Soviet civil procedural law. Saratov, 1970. 190 p.
- Denisov A.I. Theory of state and law. M., 1948. 532 p.
- Efimov A.V. The influence of economic characteristics (indicators) on the legal status of legal entities: monograph. Moscow: Prospekt, 2024. 376 p.
- Zavyalov Y.S. Personality, interests, law // Soviet justice. 1967. No. 15. pp. 6-7.
- Ioffe O.S. Selected works on civil law. 4th ed. Moscow: The Statute. 2020. 782 p.
- Lapach V.A. The system of objects of civil rights: Theory and judicial practice. St. Petersburg: Law Center Press, 2002. pp. 102-106.
- Lomidze O. Alienation of binding rights // Economy and law. 2002. Appendix to No. 6. pp. 13-16.
- Lomidze O.G. Law enforcement in the civil legislation of Russia. St. Petersburg., 2003. 533 p.
- Matuzov N.I. Personality. Rights. Democracy. Theoretical problems of subjective law. Saratov: Saratov Univ. Publishing House. 1972. 292 p.
- Meyer D.I. Russian civil law: In 2 hours. According to the revised and supplemented 8th ed., 1902. 2nd ed., ispr. M.: Statute, 2000. (Classics of Russian civil law). 829 p.
- Mikhailov S.V. Category of interest in Russian civil law. M.: Statute, 2002. 205 p.
- Murzina N.Yu. On the question of the concept of subjective property rights // Civilistic notes. Interuniversity collection of scientific papers. Moscow: Statute, 2001. 397 p.
- Ozhegov S.I. Dictionary of the Russian language / Edited by N.Y. Shvedova. 18th ed. M., 1987. 796 p.
- Pevsner A.G. The concept and types of subjective civil rights. M., 1961. 245 p.
- Rybalov A.O. Absolute rights and legal relations // Law studies. 2006. No. 1. pp. 129-142.
- Theory of State and law / Edited by A.B. Vengerov. 3rd ed., ispr. and add. M.: Omega-L. 2006. 608 p.
- Tolstoy Yu.K. On the theory of legal relations. L.: Leningrad University Press, 1959. 88 p.
- Trubetskoy E.N. Encyclopedia of Law. St. Petersburg: "Publishing House of Lan". 1999. 217 p.
- Filippov P.M. Judicial protection and justice in the USSR. Saratov, 1987. 183 p.
- Filippov P.M., Belonozhkin A.Y. A new definition of subjective civil law and its abuse. Volgograd: VA of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, 2009. 248 p.
- Khropanyuk V.N. Theory of state and law // Edited by V.G. Strekozov. M.: Dabakhov, Tkachev, Dimov. 1995. 384 p.
- Chegovadze L.A., Kuflin A.S. Socio-legal purpose of the category "subjective civil law" // Lawyer. 2007. No. 3 // SPS "ConsultantPlus".
- Cherdantsev A.F. Theory of state and law. Moscow: Yurayt. 2001. 429 p.
- Chertova N.M. Absolute rights in the system of civil relations // file:///C:/Users/shvedkova/Downloads/absolyutnye-prava-v-sisteme-grazhdanskih-pravootnosheniy.pdf
- Shershenevich G.F. General theory of law: A textbook. Issue 3. M., 1995 (based on the edition of 1910-1915). 556 p.
- Yakovlev A. S. Property rights as objects of civil legal relations. Theory and practice. M.: Os-89, 2009. 192 p.
Supplementary files
