Email this article Scientific discourse on the balance of interests in law
- Authors: ZAVGORODNIAIA A.A.1
-
Affiliations:
- Donbass Law Academy
- Issue: Vol 6, No 4 (2022)
- Pages: 512-522
- Section: General Theory and History of Law and the State
- URL: https://journal-vniispk.ru/2587-9340/article/view/303880
- ID: 303880
Cite item
Full Text
Abstract
The features, problems and prospects of scientific discourse on the balance of interests in law are considered. It is noted that today the balance of interests in law has acquired the value of not only value, but rational discourse, which is based on the search for some reasonable relationship between private and public interests. Different approaches to the definition, establishment of a balance of interests in law are given, approaches to the study of the essence of the balance of interests in the theory of law, as well as their branch differences in different legal sciences, which consider such a phenomenon as a balance of interests, as consent, as an agreed result, are considered, as a state of optimal conflict or lack of conflict, as a general legal, constitutional value, a legal method, as a means, etc. The variety of approaches confirms the complexity of the phenomenon of balance in law. The main discussion is in relation to the hierarchy of values and interests, as well as the criteria for admissibility of the priority of interests in the procedures for their balancing. Based on the analysis of a wide range of scientific studies on the balance in law, the balance of interests in law is considered as an element of a more general phenomenon in law. The purpose of the study is to establish the systemic characteristics of balance as a multidimensional phenomenon in law (reality), its prerequisites. The methodological basis includes the use of general scientific and special research methods. Separate methods of analysis, generalization, reconstruction of theories are used, applied within the framework of axiological, structural-functional, formal-legal, comparative-legal approaches. It is concluded that today the balance in law remains a concept, the semantic and content completeness of which is rather uncertain, and the pluralism of views on the definition of the essence of the balance of interests is due to various methodological approaches in its study and the goals set by the researcher, in connection with which the use of teleological approach allows us to recognize it as a goal, with an instrumental, pragmatic one – a means of effective legal regulation, with a structural-functional (systemic) approach to law – balance is an element of legal consciousness and legal ideology, a principle; with the formal legal (jurisprudence of concepts) – the concept; in the socio-humanitarian approach – as a state of social interests.
About the authors
Anastasiia A. ZAVGORODNIAIA
Donbass Law Academy
Author for correspondence.
Email: nastacija@mail.ru
ORCID iD: 0000-0001-5120-7018
Candidate of Law, Associate Professor of Civil Law Disciplines Department
Russian Federation, 9 Lebedinsky St., Donetsk 283049, Donetsk People's RepublicReferences
- Zhuykov V.M. Printsip verkhovenstva prava i pravovyye standarty osushchestvleniya pravosudiya: problemy ikh realizatsii v Rossii [The rule of law principle and legal norms for implementation: problems of implementation in Russia]. Verkhovenstvo prava kak faktor ekonomiki [The Rule of Law as a Factor in the Economy]. Moscow, Mysl Publ., 2013, 673 p. (In Russian).
- Lebedev V.M. Pravosudiye v sovremennom mire [Justice in the Modern World] Moscow, Norma Publ., Scientific Publishing Center INFRA-M, 2014, 720 p. (In Russian).
- Podorozhna T.S. Pravovyy poryadok: teoretyko-metodolohichni zasady konstytutsionalizatsiyi: dis. … d-ra yurid. nauk [Legal Order: Theoretical and Methodological Principles of Constitutionalization. Dr. jurid. sci. diss.]. Kyiv, 2017, 503 p. (In Ukranian).
- Khaliulin V.E. Soglasovaniye interesov sub”yektov prava kak predposylka formirovaniya grazhdanskogo obshchestva v Rossiyskoy Federatsii: dis. … kand. yurid. nauk [Coordination of Interests of Subjects of Law as a Prerequisite for the Formation of Civil Society in the Russian Federation. Cand. jurid. sci. diss.]. Saratov, 2008, 228 p. (In Russian).
- Bondar N.S. Sudebnyy konstitutsionalizm v Rossii v svete konstitutsionnogo pravosudiya [Judicial Constitutionalism in Russia in the Light of Constitutional Justice]. Moscow, Norma Publ., Infra-M Publ., 2011, 544 p. (In Russian).
- Chervonyuk V.I. Mekhanizm i zakonomernosti pravoobrazovaniya (deystviya pozitivnogo prava) v sovremennoy Rossii: yuridicheskaya konstruktsiya i pravovaya real’nost’ (v shesti vypuskakh). Vyp. 4. Soglasovaniye interesov kak metod pravovogo regulirovaniya i innovatsionnyy vid (tip) sovremennykh zakonodatel’nykh tekhnologiy [The mechanism and regularities of right education (action of a positive law) in modern Russia: a legal design and legal reality (in six releases). Release 4. Coordination of interests as method of legal regulation and innovative type (type) of modern legislative technologies]. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta Ministerstva vnutrennikh del Rossii – Vestnik of Moscow University of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, 2013, no. 3, pp. 67-74. (In Russian).
- Maltsev V.A. Balans interesov v sfere obespecheniya bezopasnosti: ponyatiye i mekhanizm gosudarstvenno-pravovogo regulirovaniya [Balance of interests in the field of security: the concept and mechanism of state and legal regulation]. Konstitutsionnoye i munitsipal’noye pravo – Constitutional and Municipal Law, 2007, no. 18, pp. 5-10. (In Russian).
- Kalinskiy I.V., Chervonyuk V.I. Balans interesov kak ideya prava, obshchepravovoy kontsept (pravovaya tsennost’), yuridicheskaya konstruktsiya i tekhnologii obespecheniya [Balance of interests as an idea of law, general legal concept (legal value), legal construction and security technologies]. Kriminologicheskiy zhurnal – Criminological Journal, 2021, no. 3, pp. 37-43. doi: 10.24412/2687-0185-2021-3-37-43. (In Russian).
- Vavilin E.V. Osushchestvleniye i zashchita grazhdanskikh prav [Exercise and Protection of Civil Rights]. Moscow, Wolters Kluwer Publ., 2009, 338 p. (In Russian).
- Pyankova A.F. Kontseptsiya balansa interesov i eye mesto v grazhdanskom prave Rossii [The notion of the balance of interests and its place in Russian civil law]. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Yuridicheskiye nauki – Bulletin of Perm University. Legal Sciences, 2014, no. 2 (24), pp. 117-130. (In Russian).
- Nikologorskaya E.I. Grazhdansko-pravovaya kharakteristika interesov aktsionerov i aktsionernogo obshchestva i ikh balansa: dis. … kand. yurid. nauk [Civil Law Characteristics of the Interests of Shareholders and a Joint-Stock Company and Their Balance. Cand. jurid. sci. diss.]. Moscow, 2009, 186 p. (In Russian).
- Trofimov V.V. Interesy v prave: sotsial’no-interaktivnaya priroda i rol’ v formirovanii elementov pravovoy materii [Interests in law: the social and interactive nature and role in the formation of legal matter]. Materialy Vserossiyskoy nauchnoy konferentsii: «Interesy v prave. Zhidkovskiye chteniya» [Materials of the All-Russian Scientific Conference: “Interests in Law. Zhidkov’s Readings”]. Moscow, Peoples’ Friendship University of Russia Publ., 2017, pp. 82-98. (In Russian).
- Chervonyuk V.I. Innovatsii v prave: sovremennyye yuridicheskiye tekhnologii v kontekste tsifrovoy real’nosti. Stat’ya 5. Tekhnologii soglasovaniya (legitimatsii soglasovannykh) interesov v zakonodatel’noy deyatel’nosti [Innovation in law: modern legal technologies in the context of digital reality. Article 5. Technologies for reconciliation (legitimization of agreed) interests in legislative activity]. Vestnik ekonomicheskoy bezopasnosti – Bulletin of Economic Security, 2021, no. 2, pp. 37-45. doi: 10.24412/2414-3995-2021-2-37-45. (In Russian).
- Shugurov M.V. Balans i disbalans kak kategorii pravovoy real’nosti: sistemno-sinergeticheskiy podkhod [Balance and Unbalance as Categories of Law Reality: Systematic and Synergetic Approach]. Rossiyskiy zhurnal pravovykh issledovaniy – Russian Journal of Legal Studies, 2016, vol. 3, no. 1 (6), pp. 87-98. (In Russian).
- Khorunzhiy S.N. Pravovoy balans kak samostoyatel’naya yuridicheskaya tsennost’: mekhanizmy ego obespecheniya i regulirovaniya [Legal Balance as an Independent Legal Value: Mechanisms for its Provision and Regulation]. Voronezh, Voronezh State University Publishing House, 2019, 526 p. (In Russian).
- Romashov R.A. Pravo: normativnost’ i deviantnost’ [Law: Normativity and Deviance]. Saint-Petersburg, Aletheia Publ., 2018, 272 p. (In Russian).
- Belousov S.A. Zakonodatel’nyy disbalans (Doktrina. Teoriya. Praktika) [Legislative imbalance (Doctrine. Theory. Practice)]. Saratov, Saratov State Law Academy Publ., 2015, 472 p. (In Russian).
- Punchenko S.I. Sotsial’naya effektivnost’ prava v sovremennoy Rossii (teoreticheskiy aspekt): dis. … kand. yurid. nauk [Social Efficiency of Law in Modern Russia (Theoretical Aspect). Cand. jurid. sci. diss.]. Krasnodar, 2016, 169 p. (In Russian).
- Repyeva P.V. K probleme issledovaniya yuridicheskoy prirody kategorii balansa [The problem of research of the legal nature of the category balance]. Mezhdunarodnyy nauchno-issledovatel’skiy zhurnal – International Research Journal, 2015, no. 9-1 (40), pp. 88-91. (In Russian).
Supplementary files
