Vol 27, No 5 (2022)
- Year: 2022
- Published: 11.11.2022
- Articles: 23
- URL: https://journal-vniispk.ru/1810-0201/issue/view/19745
Full Issue
МЕТОДОЛОГИЯ ОБРАЗОВАНИЯ
Philosophical and methodological strategies for language learning: formalization and contextualization
Abstract
The study of language as a means of communication, storage and transmission of human experience has led to the formation of two different philosophical and methodological strategies in scientific cognition: one, based on the theory of sets, considers language from the point of view of its formal structure; the other, based on the theory of systems, interprets language as a carrier of information, as a sign information system. It is proved that these strategies of language research should be characterized not so much as competing, but as mutually complementing each other, helping to reveal the specifics of the linguistic phenomenon. The main thesis of the study is reduced to the statement that an utterance, before it becomes an integral component of social knowledge, must undergo a “filtration” procedure according to two different selection criteria. The first criterion is contextual, when understandable information is extracted from the content of the sentence. The second – logical – involves the “filtering” of true judgments based on formal requirements accepted in science. While the formal-logical strategy of language research is described in some detail in the scientific literature, a systematic approach to its study needs more thorough elaboration and practical coping. An example of the mentioned double filtering of a sentence, carried out on a logical and informational basis, can be the liar's paradox. Despite the fact that many experts perceive the liar's statement “I’m lying” as a logical paradox, however, it does not affect our understanding of natural language and its use for cognitive purposes. As a result of the conducted research, the interconnection of the processes of formalization and contextualization as two key philosophical and methodological approaches to the study of language is revealed.



Topical issues of digitalization of the educational and legal space of the state
Abstract
The analysis of actual problems related to the digitalization of legal education is carried out. At the present stage, it is impossible to imagine the educational process without the digital space and the subjects of educational activity involved in it: students, teachers, specialists in the field of information technology, etc. The use of a predominant digital approach in teaching is considered, which is based on special methods of transmitting information that allows solving a large number of diverse tasks in the shortest time intervals. It is noted that there is a consistent introduction of information technologies into the educational system of our state and educational institutions teaching jurisprudence are also included in this system. Each of them has systems with an electronic educational environment, where tasks are performed that form competencies provided for by the state standard and curriculum, computers, electronic textbooks, educational and teaching aids. The issue of improving the effectiveness of legal educational systems is raised, since it is known what efforts the introduction of digital technologies in the learning process requires. It is concluded that in order to achieve the goal, it is not enough to provide an educational institution with digital devices, connect to the Internet and develop digital service platforms. The implementation of this process requires not only the renewal of the entire educational system, pedagogical practice, but also a transition to new models of organization of work in general, including the use of the digital construction method.



ПЕДАГОГИКА ДОШКОЛЬНОГО ОБРАЗОВАНИЯ
Development of graphomotor skills in senior preschoolers: a neuropsychological aspect
Abstract
The aim of the study is to generalize the available interdisciplinary data on the formation of graphomotor skills in older preschoolers and use them as a basis for describing the process of forming graphomotor skills in left-handed children. The essence and structure of graphomotor skills as a component of written activity is considered. In the structure of writing, graphomotor skills represent the final link in writing activity and are associated with the drawing of graphic symbols. Based on neuropsychological data on interhemispheric asymmetry in children, the necessity of developing a graphomotor skill in older preschoolers is substantiated, taking into account the dominant profile of lateralization. We consider the provisions of the theory of the level organization of movements by N.A. Bernstein as a support in the development of a graphomotor skill. Noting the level nature of the organization of written activity, attention is focused on the role of gross motor skills, posture retention and other components of background levels, without which the very implementation of the graphic skill is difficult. A scheme is proposed that reflects the indicators of the formation of graphomotor skills in older preschoolers. The following components have the leading importance in it: general motor readiness, visual-object gnosis and visual-motor coordination, elementary graphic skill. The features of pedagogical work in the formation of graphomotor skills in left-handed children are described. The novelty of the study lies in modeling the system of work on the formation of this skill of written activity based on the theory of the level organization of movements by N.A. Bernstein. The proposed system model can be used to form graphic-motor skills in left-handed children, which reflects its practical significance.



ПЕДАГОГИКА ДОПОЛНИТЕЛЬНОГО ОБРАЗОВАНИЯ
Model of the development of productive experience in children of primary school age in additional education
Abstract
The relevance of the problem under study is due to the aggravation of contradictions between the objective need of society for a culturally productive personality and the lack of knowledge about the content of productive experience as one of the targets of modern education; between the wide possibilities of additional education in the development of productive experience and the insufficient degree of realization of its potential in relation to the considered area of pedagogical research. The aim of the study is to design a model for the development of productive experience in children of primary school age in additional education. Research methods: analytical review of scientific sources, modeling. The model ensures the realization of the potential of additional education in the development of the structural components of productive experience in children of primary school age. Particular attention is paid to the study of the procedural component of the model, aimed at the use in practice of traditional and innovative methods, techniques, tools, the implementation of pedagogical conditions that ensure the effectiveness of the process under study.



Retrospective analysis of the system of socio-pedagogical prevention of criminal behavior of minors in Japan
Abstract
A retrospective analysis of the problem of prevention of criminal behavior of minors in Japan has been carried out. The relevance of the study lies in the fact that in many countries of the world and in Russia, in particular, the criminal behavior of minors remains a serious problem. The choice of Japan for the study is due, firstly, to its proximity to Russia in terms of combining the features of the “eastern” and “western” culture within the country, and secondly, the status of Japan as a state with one of the lowest juvenile crime rates in the world. On this basis, the experience of organizing the prevention of criminal behavior of minors in Japan is valuable and in demand for the domestic crime prevention system. The research uses the following methods: analysis and synthesis, induction and deduction, analogy, generalization. Japanese society has always been built on a special sense of collectivism, a strict hierarchy of relationships (including within the family), unquestioning subordination of “younger” to “older”, which had a deterrent preventive effect on adolescents, “protecting” them from committing criminal acts. Based on the results of the retrospective analysis, conclusions are drawn about the causes and main trends of juvenile delinquency in Japan at various stages of the formation of this state, as well as about the features of the development of the system of prevention of this negative social phenomenon, which can be useful for improving the activities of subjects of juvenile delinquency prevention in modern Russia.



THEORY AND METHODS OF FOREIGN LANGUAGE TEACHING
Teaching English on a linguocognitive basis: an extralinguistic aspect
Abstract
The features of the nonverbal side of communication in teaching English at a language university are considered. The basic postulates of linguocognitive science are given, justifying the importance of attention not only to language, but also extralinguistic means of communication in a foreign language lesson. The main obstacles that do not allow to focus properly on the nonverbal aspect of communication in English classes in the university environment are indicated. The close connection of gestures, facial expressions, body movements with the linguistic and cultural space within which they exist is substantiated. Classifications of such extralinguistic means are given with special emphasis on various types of gestures. Based on the analysis of a wide range of scientific papers on the problem of research, two large groups of functions of nonverbal communication tools and a number of private functions included in them are identified. The possible roles of extralinguistic means of communication in foreign language classes and scenarios of their use are determined. The possibility of widespread use of video materials, in particular, authentic Englishlanguage feature films for teaching students of a language university the non-verbal side of communication is substantiated. An example of one of the possible sequences of such training in extralinguistic means of communication on a linguocognitive basis is given.



Monitoring and assessment of students’ foreign language proficiency: problems and solutions
Abstract
Topical problems of control in teaching a foreign language at a university were discussed. The issues related to the definition of the place of control in the educational process, with the implementation of its functions are raised. Special attention is paid to the specifics of the control of receptive and productive types of speech activity. Examples of tasks that allow to identify the formation of speech skills and language skills in students are given.



Foreign language teacher: modern requirements for the challenges of the time
Abstract
The issues of the state of the problem of the ability and readiness of a foreign language teacher to respond to the challenges of the time in connection with the rapidly changing reality, when he has to use various communication channels to motivate productive interaction in the classroom and thereby contribute to the creation of an academic community, the professional development of students. The set of teacher competencies necessary for solving the tasks of teaching, educating and developing future specialists in foreign language classes is considered in detail, namely: competence in the field of personal qualities, competence in setting goals and objectives of pedagogical activity, competence in motivating students to carry out educational activities, competence in developing a program activity and pedagogical decision-making, competence in providing the information basis of pedagogical activity, as well as competence in the organization of pedagogical activity. The importance of the teacher's ability to lifelong learning and selfimprovement is noted, which is inextricably linked with the development of information and communication technologies competencies, including. In addition, a foreign language teacher should form the same qualities in students, because in a rapidly changing world, the autonomy of a student is one of the conditions for his success. The following competencies were identified: methodical, information and communication and linguodidactic, the relevance of an individual approach in teaching was noted, as well as the ability of the teacher to motivate students throughout the entire academic time.



Methodical model of teaching students of language specialties to a foreign language written speech utterance based on the method of mutual assessment
Abstract
A model of the methodical system of teaching foreign language written speech utterance to students of language specialties based on the method of mutual assessment has been developed. The methodical system is understood as a set of hierarchically arranged key components of the language learning process. Structurally, the methodical system includes four parts: 1) goal setting, which includes the social order and the needs of students in mastering specific skills or competencies; 2) methodology, including the main pedagogical and methodical approaches, as well as the principles by which the approaches will be implemented in the learning process; 3) the content part, including the main teaching methods, forms, conditions, means and content of training; 4) the performance assessment part, which includes the results training and their evaluation. The methodical system is based on systematic, personality-oriented, activity-based and communicativecognitive approaches. These approaches are implemented in practice through pedagogical and methodical principles. Such methodological principles of teaching students foreign language written utterance as the principle of functionality, the principle of speech orientation, the principle of novelty, the principle of interrelation of all types of real activity, the principle of step-by-step learning, the principle of combining communicative tasks and training exercises are presented and described in detail. The training is carried out on the basis of the method of mutual assessment and the communicative method of teaching. Also, at the procedural stages of training, students use training exercises to better master the material. The content of teaching written speech to students of a language university meets modern requirements for the level of language proficiency and the program requirements of the university. The teaching tools used include traditional means (Educational and Methodical Complexes in a foreign language) and innovative means (a closed group in the “VKontakte” social network operating on the principle of blog technology). All components of the methodological system are described in detail.



Formation of foreign language written and speech competence of students of linguistic directions in the conditions of learning in cooperation
Abstract
The definition of written and speech competence is given, and criteria for its formation, such as the ability to fully disclose the topic; consistency, reasonableness and consistency of presentation; the variety of vocabulary and the correctness of its use, as well as the correctness, complexity and variety of grammatical structures are proposed. Various forms of joint classroom and extracurricular educational and cognitive activities in the preparation of a writing practice are considered, such as discussion of the essay topic, mutual verification and mutual spelling and punctuation dictation, preparation of presentations on new material. The scheme of organization of joint classroom and extracurricular activities of students in the preparation of assignments for written practice has been developed, described and tested. According to given scheme, students work in small groups in MS Teams, preparing presentations explaining various aspects of essay writing, developing control questions and practical tasks for other students, as well as discussing possible ideas for the next essay. An experiment that demonstrates a higher efficiency of the formation of written-speech competence of students of linguistic directions in the conditions of learning in cooperation is described. Students of the experimental group prepared tasks in small groups leading discussions in MS Teams, while in the control group, students worked individually, performing the same tasks as in the experimental group. Higher scores for final essays in the experimental group are explained by a deeper study of the material due to its discussion with other members of the small group and the development of a clear argument through discussions on the topics of upcoming essays, as well as through mutual verification of written works, allowing students to critically approach their own works.



Teaching students a foreign language in a children's camp: psychological and pedagogical conditions
Abstract
The analysis of modern approaches and experimental practice of the implementation of educational programs of summer language camps is carried out. The relevance of the research is based on the increasing processes of globalization and socio-cultural integration, stimulating the development of intercultural communications and linguistic competencies around the world. The purpose of the study is to substantiate the organizational, pedagogical and didactic features of the implementation of educational programs of the summer language camp. Based on the analysis of literary sources and methodical materials, the target orientation and format of the implemented programs are specified, the necessary didactic and educational conditions are determined. The pedagogical potential of the summer language camp, the most achievable psychological and pedagogical results of pedagogical influence are revealed. The camp is positioned as an effective extracurricular form of linguistic education, which has a powerful motivating effect, provides active speech practice, allow to overcome language barriers and familiarize with the culture of the peoples of the world. The main forms of extracurricular activities that ensure the effective assimilation of linguistic skills are highlighted, the role of linguistic and pedagogical support in the development of language competencies is shown. The research materials can be useful for practical teachers, organizers of intercultural cooperation programs, in the development and implementation of projects and educational programs of summer camps for children and youth.



The method of projects as a progressive method of teaching foreign language communication in the mainstream of modern education
Abstract
It is proved that the fundamental purpose of teaching a foreign language is the formation of a foreign language communicative competence, that is, the ability to communicate with representatives of a foreign language culture, within which it is necessary to activate the main types of foreign language speech activity: speaking, listening, reading, writing. It is proved that the development of foreign language communicative competence is impossible without addressing the peculiarities of foreign culture. The experience of teaching foreign languages shows that it is often difficult for students to formulate an integral, logical and complete statement on their own due to the difference in cultural differences at the verbal and non-verbal levels of communication. The main difficulties are related to the fact that comprehensive knowledge of a foreign language is necessary for the implementation of foreign language communication, the formation of which is becoming particularly relevant in the conditions of modern education. In connection with the above, the question of finding an effective methodology for the development of foreign language communicative competence is raised. It is assumed that the project method allows you to build the learning process in such a way that students will be placed in conditions as close as possible to the conditions of real communication, which, in turn, will contribute to immersion in the specifics of someone else's culture. In addition, the project method allows solving the problem of the formation of an educational motive, since the mentioned method implements the principles of personalityoriented learning, according to which students can choose the topic of a lesson in a foreign language that will correspond to the sphere of their interests.



ИСТОРИОГРАФИЯ
Reflection of the Orthodox history of Eastern Transbaikal in the late 1920s – early 1930s in the documents of the State Archive of the Russian Federation and the problems of its study by sources
Abstract
The assessment of the degree of reflection of the history of Orthodoxy in Eastern Transbaikalia in the late 1920s – early 1930s in the funds of the State Archive of the Russian Federation is given. The history of the Orthodox Church in the region at the time under review today has found only partial reflection on the pages of scientific publications. This determines the importance of archival sources and indicates the relevance of the study. The funds of regional archives on the territory of Transbaikalia on the history of the Orthodox Church in the region in the late 1920s – early 1930s contain a small amount of information. The main repository for today is the State Archive of the Russian Federation. It is noted that the discovered cases allow us to speak of a fragmentary reflection of the issues under consideration. The information is dispersed throughout the documents. Voluminous cases are presented on individual facts, but there are few of them. There are also generalizing cases containing a variety of information. It is noted that individual events can be reconstructed in sufficient detail. The reporting provided from the field on the state of religious processes in Eastern Transbaikalia at the time under review was brief and in some cases controversial. It is concluded that the funds of the State Archive of the Russian Federation allow to partially restore the history under consideration. Further work with sources is required to recreate the full picture.



To the issue of the historiographic systematization (on the materials of dissertations on the history of the Tambov Governorate and region)
Abstract
For the first time, a variant of the historiographic systematization of scientific works (dissertations) on the history of the Tambov Governorate and region has been developed. The definition of historiography as the history of historical science is taken as a basis, which removes the discrepancy in the interpretation of the category. Due to the presence of different methodological approaches of individual researchers to the construction of analysis, a need has arisen for systematizing the work of historiographers, which seems appropriate in studying the development of historiography proper as a science. Actual, in the light of the increase in the number of studies of local lore, is the historiography of historical regional studies. The purpose of this research is to determine some of the foundations of the historiographic systematization of scientific research on the history of the Tambov Region. The object of the study is dissertations as a mass historiographic source, the most significant in a detailed study of the phenomena and processes of work, prepared by professional historians. The chronological framework of published works is the second half of the 20th – early 21st century. The main direction is the analysis of quantitative historiographic indicators. A content analysis technique was used, which involves a selection of sources according to specified criteria. The analysis carried out allows us to identify the range of issues that aroused the greatest interest of the authors, promising areas of historical research. It also serves as the initial stage for continuing the systematization of the historiography of the Tambov region, the basis for the analysis of specific works.



NATIONAL HISTORY
Development of a map of rural settlements of the Russian population of the Tara County in the 16th–19th centuries
Abstract
The purpose of the research is to identify the factors that determine the process of forming a map of rural settlements of the Tara County in the 16th – 19th centuries and stages of development and settlement of the territory. Among the factors, the author singles out the policy of the state in the field of settling Siberia in general and the Tara County in particular, and the desire of peasants to develop new territories in search of solid arable land. The stages of the emergence of new Russian villages on the map of the Irtysh region are revealed: late 16th century –early 17th century, when the main task was to defend the borders of the territory; 17th – the first half of the 19th century, when the growth of the Siberian population led to an increase in the need for bread and, as a result, the need to develop new lands; the second half of the 19th century, when the emergence of new settlements is the result of the state's resettlement policy. We analyze different points of view on the appearance of new villages on the map, their placement relative to the oldtimers' territories. The results of the study will be useful and interesting to scientists involved in the study of rural history, teachers of educational organizations of all levels of education and a wide range of readers who are passionate about the history of the Fatherland.



Monetary allowance of captured officers in Russia and Western countries in the 18th century
Abstract
The issues of monetary maintenance of captured officers in the wars of the 18th century have never and nowhere been the subject of special research before. Meanwhile, the study of these issues could contribute to the expansion of our knowledge about Russia’s place in the world in the early Modern period, as well as the establishment of previously unknown features of the country's development determined by Peter the Great’s transformations. The above indicates the relevance of this work and determines its purpose: to reconstruct and compare domestic and foreign practices of material support for enemy officers at the expense of the budget of the captive power throughout the 18th century. The methodological basis of the study consisted mainly of historicalcomparative and historical-typological methods. We present a periodization of the evolution of the monetary allowance of prisoners in various countries. The distinctive features of each period are identified and systematized. It is established that in the 18th century in the West, the maintenance of enemy officers went from meeting the primary needs of only individuals from among those in special need, to the regular and unconditional issuance of a permanent monetary allowance equal to the minimum salary of servicemen of the same rank of their own army. It is proved that in the studied chronological framework of the Russian model of material support for captured officers was practically in no way inferior to the Western one and in some matters was ahead of it for decades.



Peasant traditionalism during the era of the “revolutionary turning point”
Abstract
The analysis of the evolution of the peasant mentality in the historical period of the “revolutionary turning point” is carried out. The relevance of the study lies in the creation of a theoretical basis for a more detailed development of the problem of peasant traditionalism and the problem of the role of the “revolutionary turning point” generation in the crisis of the traditional peasant mentality in the first third of the 20th century. In the course of the study, analytical and historical-comparative methods were used. It is shown that the radicalization of the mood of the peasants during the years of the First Russian revolution was due to the problem of land scarcity and the spread of neo-populist ideas that worsened at the early 20th century. The war factor created the prerequisites for a new view of the peasants on the problem of the relationship between the monarchical power and the people, which contained grounds for a deep rupture of age-old traditional ties. The events of the 1917 revolution and the Civil War led to the breakdown of the traditional communal archetype in the peasant mentality, influencing the emergence of intergenerational conflicts and deepening the confrontation between the rural poor and the prosperous peasantry.



Overcoming the consequences of the breakdown of the law enforcement system of the Russian Empire in railway transport in the early years of Soviet Russia
Abstract
We examine the problems that arose as a result of the activities of the young Soviet state in the first years of its formation after the liquidation of specialized law enforcement agencies operating at railway transport facilities in tsarist Russia – the gendarmerie railway police. It is shown that the scrapping of the old law enforcement system provoked irreversible processes that had a devastating impact on the state of public order and public safety at the country’s railway transport facilities. The Civil War worsened the state of public order and public safety on the railway lines. Rail transport was on the verge of collapse. Separated and deprived of a single control center, the transport was unable to provide the necessary level of capacity. The issues of public order protection and public safety, in this regard, were relegated to a secondary plan. The primary task of the Soviet government was to maintain control over railway transport, to ensure its carrying capacity. We analyze the social relations that developed in the early years of Soviet power on railway lines in the conditions of the vacuum of specialized units and organizations directly involved in the protection of public order and ensuring public safety on railway lines. We analyze the situation in which Russian railway transport found itself after October 1917 and the circumstances that led to the creation of Soviet law enforcement agencies on railway transport.



Intra-party crisis in the CPSU and problems of state administration in 1920–1921
Abstract
Various aspects of the inner-party crisis in the CPSU, which manifested themselves especially sharply at the turn of 1920–1921, are analyzed. It is emphasized that the intra-party crisis had the most serious impact on the public administration system, since the CPSU as the ruling party constituted the organizational and personnel basis of the entire management system. Specific manifestations of crisis phenomena, their impact on the functional capabilities of government bodies are highlighted. The state of the local and regional authorities is investigated. Changes of a personal and psychological nature that have occurred in the personnel of Soviet managers are revealed. It is concluded that the management model, created during the Civil War and based solely on violence, ceased to work in peaceful conditions and there was an urgent need to improve it and change personnel in accordance with new social needs.



Peculiarities of pension coverage for disabled war veteran and their employment in Tambov Region in 40s and 50s of the 20th century
Abstract
The study of certain aspects of social adaptation and support, pension coverage and employment of disabled veterans of the Great Patriotic War allows us to clarify the peculiarities of post-war society development, development trajectories of the socialization of the military generation in the 40–50s of the 20th century. During this period, the efforts of the Soviet and party bodies to organize assistance to disabled war veterans, a significant part of whom had mental injuries and illnesses, were especially significant. Military everyday life and traumatization of combatants led to an increase in morbidity, which required a serious transformation not only of public health, but also of the system of social protection and pension legislation. The most intensive study of this problem was carried out during the war years and the first post-war decades, also in the 20s of the 21s century. The methodological peculiarities of the study of the stated problems are based on the author’s concept of attracting the works of contemporaries, primarily specialists in the field of psychiatry, practitioners of the Tambov Region, as well as the actual case histories and anamnesis of mental illness. We use materials from the state and party archives of the Tambov region, many of which are being introduced into scientific circulation for the first time. The results of the study allow us to draw a quite obvious conclusion that the central and local Soviet and party bodies made certain efforts to organize social support and employment for disabled war veterans. Highly successful, these events on medical and social work were carried out in the Tambov Region. However, in general, the lack of material resources and hardships of the post-war period did not allow for decent pension coverage and social adaptation of disabled war veterans.



FOREIGN COUNTRIES’ HISTORY
Anti-church campaign in the 1920s in Kazakhstan (on the materials of the archives of Kazakhstan)
Abstract
On the basis of archival documents, the anti-church campaign in Kazakhstan in the 1920s was studied on the seizure of church valuables under the pretext of helping the starving population of the Volga region. The purpose of the study is to analyze the regional features of this process, which influenced the further policy of the Bolsheviks in relation to churches and their property. The subject of the study is the activities of district commissions for the seizure of church valuables. Historical events are considered in dynamics, their causal relationships are revealed during the campaign period. The main goals of the anti-religious policy of the state are shown. The relevance of the study is due to the need to introduce into scientific circulation previously unused archival documents that make it possible to objectively highlight the features of the confessional policy of the Soviet state in the 1920s in Kazakhstan. The study of state-confessional relations at the regional level gives a more complete picture of the socio-political history of the designated period. The study of this problem seems to be relevant at the present time, when the role of religion in the public life of the country has noticeably intensified. The methods of scientific knowledge were used, the principles of scientific objectivity and historicism were used in the context of the problem of the relationship between the state and the national outskirts. Statistical research methods and the method of historical comparison were used to identify regional features in state-confessional relations. The retrospective method made it possible to identify the reasons for the transformation of the religious policy of the state, the attitude of the authorities towards believers in the 1920s in Kazakhstan.



U.S. policy towards Israel in the context of the Israeli-Jordanian armed clashes (1954)
Abstract
The U.S. policy towards Israel in 1954 is considered on the example of foreign policy decisions taken by the American side during the Israeli-Jordanian armed clashes. As part of the unresolved Arab-Israeli conflict, the U.S. administration considered the vector of establishing partnerships with Arab countries as one of the ways to counteract the expansion of Soviet influence in the region. When resolving the issue of the Israeli-Jordanian border conflicts, the U.S. resorted to a policy of maneuvering, trying to maintain a balanced interaction with each of the parties. Meanwhile, this did not improve relations with the Arab countries, which emphasized the ongoing U.S. financial and political assistance to Israel. There was also a cooling of relations with the Jewish state, whose government was concerned about the prevailing positive trends in relations between the Arab countries and the United States. It is concluded that by 1954 the U.S. policy towards Israel was still at the stage of its formation, which was reflected in the contradictory opinions within the U.S. administration itself when resolving issues related to the foreign policy strategy regarding the Jewish state, and manifested itself in the process of unsuccessful resolution of the IsraeliJordanian conflict.



Rethinking E. Said’s “Orientalism” in modern Western and Russian scientific discourse
Abstract
We consider the perception of the orientalist concept formulated by E. Said in modern Western and Russian science. The key works that have been published over the past 10-15 years are analyzed, inasmuch as the thirty years that have passed since the publication of E. Said’s monograph is a sufficient period for rethinking both the main postulates of his book and critical remarks addressed to it. It is concluded that the debate in the Western scientific community, caused by the publication of “Orientalism” is still mainly focused on the personality of the author himself, and sometimes on the opposition to his contemporary, the American historian and orientalist Bernard Lewis. It is emphasized that after the death of E. Said, the revisionist-minded part of the American and British oriental schools received a new reason to criticize not only “Orientalism”, but also the author himself in order to forget the work, which became the starting point for many Western orientalists to revise their attitude to the object of study. As for Russian Oriental studies, the research of orientalism in the humanities in Russia continues, despite the time that has passed since the publication of the Russian translation of the book by E. Said, and the understanding of the image of the “other” fits into the global trend of the discourse of orientalism, although with some specific features associated with the historical past of Russia.


