Vol 18, No 4 (2024)

New Research

Board Committee Diversity and Its Effects on Financial Performance: A Study of Russian Firms

Popov K.

Abstract

As one of the key elements of corporate financial architecture, corporate governance significantly affects corporate performance. However, academic papers focusing on board characteristics rarely analyze the composition of board committees, while a specific Russian regulatory and corporate environment limit an applicability of results obtained for foreign samples. This study aims to bridge these gaps by analyzing the effects of composition of key board committees on market-based indicators of financial performance of the 100 largest Russian public non-financial companies over an 8-year period from 2014 to 2021. The results of panel data analysis indicate that the professional experience diversity of members of audit, strategy and sustainability committees significantly affects Tobin’s Q and total shareholder return (TSR); moreover, the effects of experience diversity are stronger than the effects of board committee size, independence, and educational diversity. I also find that powerful CEOs can weaken the positive effects of board committee composition on corporate performance or, vice versa, mitigate some negative effects, which is in line with some previous findings. In addition to academic contribution, this study offers valuable insights for practical application while analyzing changes in corporate governance structure of Russian companies, which is especially important in the context of the massive transformations taking place since February 2022.

Journal of Corporate Finance Research. 2024;18(4):5-33
pages 5-33 views

Determinants of Financial Performance of Business Ecosystems in Russia

Ivan L.

Abstract

The scientific literature provides a comprehensive description of business ecosystems and their key advantages. However, there is a lack of thorough exploration into the practicality and efficacy of implementing business ecosystems, as well as strategies to enhance their economic impact. This study examines the impact of three key factors on the effectiveness of business ecosystems: ecosystem self sufficiency, service integration, and customer satisfaction. A sensitivity analysis of the Net Present Value (NPV) of ecosystems was conducted using discounted cash flow models for two leading Russian technology companies, IC PJSC Yandex and IC PJSC VK. The analysis focused on key drivers such as the number of active clients, average customer churn rate, digital sales funnel, and average transaction value. Ecosystem self-sufficiency significantly and variably affects NPV, with the removal of even a single business line leading to a negative impact on ecosystem value (ranging from –5 to –167%). The level of service integration has a minor influence on ecosystem NPV, with a 50% variance in subscription users leading to an NPV deviation of no more than 16%. Customer satisfaction, however, can have a substantial positive effect on ecosystem NPV, with a 1% improvement in satisfaction leading to a potential 3.7% increase in NPV. From the point of view of scientific novelty, this study allows to conclude that each factor of the effectiveness of ecosystem implementation is associated with the ability to collect and use information. For the Russian technology sector, a significant impact was identified in two of the three key factors: ecosystem self-sufficiency and customer satisfaction. The practical significance of the results of this study lies in determining the general factors that show under what conditions the introduction of an ecosystem is economically justified for the technology sector.

Journal of Corporate Finance Research. 2024;18(4):34-50
pages 34-50 views

Disclosing Current Insights: A Bibliometric Analysis of CSR and Corporate Performance Trends

Ouffa A., Elkhamlichi A.

Abstract

In this paper we conduct a systematic bibliometric analysis to explore the correlation between corporate social responsibility (CSR) and corporate performance. Despite extensive research on CSR’s financial impact, this study aims to offer fresh insights by systematically examining trends and origins in the literature from 2012 to 2022. Additionally, by integrating theoretical foundations with bibliometric analysis, our study addresses a critical gap in the literature, advancing an understanding of CSR’s role in shaping sustainable business practices. Through the analysis of 283 articles using PRISMA, we observe a significant rise in publications on CSR’s impact, especially in Chinese and American contexts, which highlight themes like sustainable development and CSR reporting. By comparing these findings to existing literature, our study contributes to understanding CSR’s evolution. We emphasize the importance of future research that explores these interactions, particularly in African countries, to comprehend CSR’s development in diverse contexts. In conclusion, our research provides original insights into the evolving relationship between CSR practices and corporate performance, guiding future scholarly exploration. This study’s novelty lies in its comprehensive analysis of recent literature, revealing emerging themes and connections in CSR and corporate performance research, thereby enhancing both its practical and theoretical relevance.

Journal of Corporate Finance Research. 2024;18(4):66-82
pages 66-82 views

Are Mergers and Acquisitions Boosting Company Performance in the Technology, Media and Telecommunications Sector?

Kostochko A., Grigorieva S.

Abstract

TMT (Technology, Media and Telecommunications) companies account for the largest number of M&A deals worldwide. This stems from their need to constantly evolve due to their high dependence on technological change. Participation in M&As is one of the fastest and most strategically promising ways to accelerate product development, gain access to new technologies, and increase competitive advantage. More than 60% of M&As are unsuccessful and do not contribute to company value creation. Will this conclusion hold for TMT companies, characterized on the one hand by rapid development and high growth rates, and on the other hand by high risks? This paper aims to assess the impact of M&As on the operating performance and value of TMT companies. In contrast to previous literature, it evaluates the M&A performance of TMT companies over the long term by applying an accounting studies logic and an economic profit model. It also contributes to
identifying the specific factors that influence the success of TMT M&As. Analyzing a sample of 203 TMT M&As completed between 2003 and 2018, we observe a positive impact on the operating performance (2.2% increase in EBITDA/Sales) and value (+$16.3m in Economic profit) of the combined companies. M&As paid for in stock outperform those paid for in cash, confirming the investment opportunity theory. Domestic M&As are the most efficient due to cultural similarities. We also find a negative impact of the acquirer’s R&D intensity on post-M&A performance due to the technology substitution effect. Our findings will be useful to managers and boards for deciding whether to participate in TMT M&As and in understanding the factors that influence the success of these deals.

Journal of Corporate Finance Research. 2024;18(4):51-65
pages 51-65 views

Social Norms and Cost of Equity: Empirical Examination in Indonesia

Cahyaningdyah D., Abiprayu K.B., Ridloah S., Wicaksari E.A.

Abstract

This paper provides evidence of the effect of social norms, as measured by sin stock status, on the cost of equity capital. We consider Indonesian publicly traded sin stocks that produce alcohol and tobacco. While previous studies focused on whether sin and saint stocks have different financing preferences, we examine how these companies are charged differently in terms of their cost of equity capital. Our research sample consists of companies listed on the Indonesian Stock Exchange from 2016 to 2020. Regression analysis proves that sin stock status has a significant influence on equity capital costs. There is an extra premium for sin stocks, as they are perceived to be riskier by investors in the market. Our results make a significant
contribution to the emerging literature on social norm-based investing, demonstrating a major impact on both corporate finance and investment management decisions. The study’s sample is restricted to publicly traded companies in Indonesia from 2016 to 2020, potentially limiting the generalizability of its findings to other countries or periods. Further research could broaden the scope of analysis and delve deeper into the factors that influence the cost of equity for sin stocks in various contexts.

Journal of Corporate Finance Research. 2024;18(4):83-91
pages 83-91 views

Influence of Ownership Structure on the Innovation Activity of South Asian Companies at Different Life Cycle Stages

Tolstov N.

Abstract

The lack of understanding management of corporate and financial innovation management in South Asia raises the fear of the declining effects of new technologies. Therefore, it is of practical interest to compare the estimates of the impact of ownership concentration in different innovation-intensive industries to minimize the agency problem among managers and shareholders. The paper provides an econometric analysis using panel regression of model testing on companies from technologically sophisticated industries, such as the Heavy and Light Industry, Information Technology (IT), and Consumer Staples from South Asia in different life cycles stages from 2015 to 2020. The South Asian market is volatile and receptive to innovations, but R&D capacity in some countries remains low. The paper provides a better understanding of the relationship between the concentration of different forms of ownership and the intensity of innovation, using industry
specifics and life cycle stages. It’s known that institutional investors are still interested in developing new digital marketing channels by competing with industry “disruptors” due to the lack of necessary strength in the IT industry along with barriers to cross-border investment. The paper confirms a linear and inverted U-shaped relationship between different forms of ownership structure and innovation activity. The results allow focusing on industrial and cultural differences to avoid agency and resource conflicts for majority shareholders of the company to build effective corporate governance, achieving strategic goals and minimizing the risks of improper management decisions in R&D.

Journal of Corporate Finance Research. 2024;18(4):92-110
pages 92-110 views

Multifactor Trend Model of Sustainable Company Growth in the Context of Competition and Inflation

Belykh V.

Abstract

The present research analyzes corporate growth against the background of competition and inflation, with a focus on the sustainable growth concept. The existing sustainable growth models are more suitable for solving the inverse problem when funding sources are defined at a predetermined growth rate, and less effective for solving the direct problem of sales volume planning when initial data is known. This is due to the fact that traditional models leave out external growth factors. Although inflation models of sustainable growth have remedied the situation, they are still dismissive of competition. The offered multifactor trend model of sustainable growth bridges this gap by taking into consideration the key growth drivers: investment ratio, asset turnover, return on sales, financial leverage and dynamics of product and resource prices. Differential and integral calculus methods were applied to develop the model, and financial ratios are considered as dynamic values described by the trends that are indicative of the external environment impact. The model potential is exemplified in various industries. It provides an opportunity to model the company’s entire life cycle, including a period of decline, and may be used as a strategic planning tool. The model describes natural, typical and logistics growth and may be used at the early stages of the life cycle when data is limited.

Journal of Corporate Finance Research. 2024;18(4):111-124
pages 111-124 views

Assessing the Sustainability of Russian Iron and Steel Companies Amid a Structural Crisis

Kuriatnikov R., Shapoval S.

Abstract

In the present paper the authors developed and tested the sustainability index of Russian iron and steel companies against the background of a structural crisis caused by the sanctions of 2022. Six companies with public reporting, including Nornickel and United Company RUSAL, were analyzed. The index comprises financial sustainability (Altman’s Z-score), operation flexibility, strategic planning horizon, economic value added (EVA), as well as environmental and social aspects. It was established that companies that actively adapt such strategies as market and commodity diversification, supply chain management and environmental standard integration exhibit stronger sustainability. For example, Nornickel managed to
redirect export from Europe to Asia, maintaining its financial stability despite a reduction in EBITDA by 17%. When RUSAL came up against supply chain disruption and an increase in costs, it recouped a part of losses by expanding in Asian markets and domestic operations. Practical recommendations based on the research comprise extending the planning horizon, reducing reliance on a single product or region and reinforcing the environmental and social sustainability. These conclusions confirm the hypothesis that companies that have gained experience in crisis management overcome new challenges with greater success.

Journal of Corporate Finance Research. 2024;18(4):125-135
pages 125-135 views

The Mediating Effect of Access to Capital in the Impact of Financial Literacy and Financial Inclusion on SME Sustainability

Ekayani N.N., Kartana I.W., Putra I.M., Diviariesty K., Darma D.C., Setini M.

Abstract

This study aims to examine the mediating role of access to capital in the impact of financial literacy and financial inclusion on SME sustainability. The object of the study is SMEs in Bali operating in the fashion sector. The total sample consisted of 277 SME leaders. Data was collected using a questionnaire tested with PLS-SEM. The results showed a significant and direct influence of financial literacy and financial inclusion on access to capital. Meanwhile, neither financial literacy nor financial inclusion by itself has a significant effect on SME sustainability. Only access to capital has a significant impact on SME sustainability. However, our findings show that access to capital can play a significant role in mediating the impact of financial literacy and financial inclusion on SME sustainability. In the context of SMEs, the results of the current study will be of particular interest to businesses focusing on fashion, showing that access to capital is an essential pillar in addition to financial literacy and inclusion. Access to capital is used as a mediating variable in the model for SME sustainability, whereas previous papers only focused on the influence of financial inclusion and financial literacy on SME sustainability. Including access to capital provides greater research insight. Our results show that, to develop, SMEs must foster financial management and instill technological knowledge to facilitate access to information on financial institution services.

Journal of Corporate Finance Research. 2024;18(4):136-151
pages 136-151 views